AI Trends

Pangram Determines Award-Winning Peruvian Novel Was 99% AI-Generated, Publisher Still Backs Author

The DecoderUpdated Nov 19 04:30

AI summary

AI detection tool Pangram determined that 99% of Peruvian writer David Silva Rojas’s award-winning novel Donde el agua trabaja was AI-generated, but Mexican publisher Almadía upheld the award after reviewing documents submitted by the author. Pangram also classified more than 80% of the text in the author’s interviews, articles, and Instagram denial statement as AI-generated. The U.S. Authors Guild warned that decisions should not be made solely on the basis of AI detection tools.

Why read this

AI score 62

The controversy highlights the limits of evidence when AI text detection enters literary award decisions, as well as the differing attitudes of publishers and writers’ organizations toward detection results.

Topics

Tags

Body

AI detection tool Pangram flags 99 percent of the award-winning novel "Donde el agua trabaja" by Peruvian author David Silva Rojas as AI-generated. Despite these allegations, Mexican publisher Almadía is standing by the award after reviewing documents from the author, according to an essay in The Point Magazine . According to the newspaper El País, Pangram had also attributed more than 80 percent of text from interviews, an essay, and the author's Instagram denial to AI.

In her essay, the author accuses Latin American critics of ignoring Pangram's test results and dismissing the allegations wholesale as racist. She compares the debate to the confirmed use of AI by Thélyson Orélien, as well as accusations involving the Caine Prize and Jamir Nazir, who kept his award. She also argues that literary juries often favor clichéd stories about minorities, which language models can easily imitate . Publisher Gallimard reportedly plans to screen manuscripts with Pangram starting next year.

In the US, the Authors Guild represents writers' interests. The organization warns against using AI detectors as the sole basis for decisions, even though Pangram reliably identified human-written texts as such in its tests .

Source

The Decoder