AI Trends

Anthropic Surges Then Retreats in Trading Debut as U.S. Stocks Plunge in Tandem

WallstreetcnUpdated Nov 20 09:27

AI summary

Anthropic went public at an offering price of $83, rose to $111.50 after opening, and then pulled back to close at $97, gaining 17% on its first day. During the same period, the Nasdaq swung from a gain of more than 2% to a 2.25% loss. The article attributes the volatility to short selling of AMD, the withdrawal of more than $100 billion in liquidity through IPO fundraising, negative-gamma hedging, and pressure from options expiration.

Why read this

SelectedAI score 83

The article links Anthropic’s first-day pullback to pressure on AI stocks, liquidity drained by IPOs, and negative-gamma hedging, offering a multifactor explanation for the market volatility.

Topics

Tags

Body · AI translation

On November 19, Anthropic went public at $83 and immediately surged to $111.50 at the open, electrifying the market. But the opening price proved to be the high, and the stock then retreated steadily, closing at $97 and narrowing its gain to 17%.

Meanwhile, the broader U.S. stock market also surged before reversing course—the Nasdaq went from gaining more than 2% at the open to closing down 2.25%, a single-day swing of more than 4 percentage points. The S&P 500 shed about $1.3 trillion in market capitalization that day, closely matching the scale of Anthropic’s IPO fundraising.

During U.S. trading, short-selling firm Hunterbrook published a report announcing a short position in AMD, weighing on the entire AI sector. The IPO’s more than $100 billion in financing drained market liquidity, while market makers’ extreme negative-gamma positioning and pressure from monthly options expiration compounded the strain, becoming the main drivers of the market’s violent swings. Anthropic’s first day of trading was supposed to reinforce faith in AI, but it unexpectedly turned into a stress test.

The Open: Everything Looked Promising

Before the U.S. market opened on Thursday, November 19, a long-absent sense of optimism filled the market.

Anthropic listed at an offering price of $83, above the upper end of its previous roadshow range, corresponding to a valuation of about $1.1 trillion and setting a record for the largest IPO fundraising in history. The news lifted U.S. stock futures across the board overnight.

At 9:30 a.m. Eastern Time, the Nasdaq Composite promptly surged more than 2%, while the S&P 500 rose in tandem, briefly sending market sentiment soaring. At the time, the market widely interpreted the largest technology IPO in history as a strong sign that the AI trade remained healthy.

Jake Behan, head of capital markets at Direxion, said: “The market had been debating whether the AI trade had gone too far, so first seeing Nvidia beat expectations and then seeing traders willing to chase Anthropic above its offering price is a fairly significant signal.” “It doesn’t put an end to every valuation debate, but it strongly suggests the market isn’t ready to give up on this trade.”

However, the good times did not last.

The Open Was the High

Shortly after the opening bell, a report carried by Bloomberg and other media outlets quickly spread across Wall Street trading desks: “Anthropic’s IPO reportedly allocated almost no shares to most institutional buyers.”

The news instantly put the market on alert. ZeroHedge said there were two possible interpretations:

Either the underwriters were extremely confident in demand and deliberately restricted institutional allocations to ensure the stock would explode after listing;

Or institutions were simply unwilling to buy at $83, leaving the shares to be placed with retail investors who were less price-sensitive.

Short-selling firm Hunterbrook published a report disclosing that it had shorted AMD and alleging that the company continued to provide chip firmware update services to entities blacklisted by the United States, while also maintaining ties to some of the companies previously involved in Nvidia’s regulatory controversy.

AMD responded immediately: “These claims misrepresent AMD’s business practices and partnerships.”

But the statement failed to halt the decline. AMD fell more than 9% that day, dragging the entire chip and AI sectors lower.

At Noon, Anthropic Was Sold Off as Soon as It Opened

At noon Eastern Time, Anthropic officially began trading, opening at $111.50, more than 34% above its $83 offering price.

Yet the stock was sold off the instant it opened—the logic of “selling the news” immediately took hold. At nearly the same moment, the broader market also fell to its intraday low.

According to The New York Times, the move closely resembled SpaceX’s listing in June this year, when the stock likewise surged at the open before quickly retreating, a pattern investors were already mentally prepared for.

Anthropic ultimately closed at $97 per share, narrowing its gain to 17%.

Afternoon: The Decline Accelerates into a Broad Rout

The sell-off spread further in the afternoon U.S. session.

The Nasdaq reversed from a gain of more than 2% at the open to close down 2.25%, a single-day swing of more than 4 percentage points. The S&P 500 closed down 2%, with all 11 sectors in the red, wiping out about $1.3 trillion in market value in a single day—almost equivalent to Anthropic’s roughly $1.3 trillion valuation at its listing.

The sell-off was not merely a technology-stock problem. Every constituent of the S&P 500 consumer discretionary sector was down by the afternoon, led by Williams-Sonoma, whose third-quarter results showed sales falling short of analysts’ expectations. Strong consumer spending has been a major pillar of the U.S. economy’s resilience this year, making investors particularly sensitive to signs of slowing consumption.

The VIX fear index rose to nearly 28 that day, VVIX—the volatility of volatility—surpassed 125, and the S&P 500’s one-month implied correlation climbed in tandem. Analysts said all these indicators pointed to a broad risk-off environment rather than an isolated sell-off in individual stocks.

It was also the S&P 500’s sixth consecutive trading-day decline, its longest losing streak since April 2024.

Nomura strategist Charlie McElligott had previously warned that, amid the combined “fourfold risk” of Nvidia’s earnings, Anthropic’s listing, and options expiration, market makers’ “negative gamma” exposure had risen to its highest level since 2019.

When market makers are in a negative-gamma position, they are forced to hedge in the direction of the market—selling as the market falls and thereby amplifying the decline. A large influx of 0DTE (zero-days-to-expiration) options flow in the afternoon further overwhelmed support from longer-dated positions.

Second, the IPO itself “drained” market liquidity.

The IPO raised a total of $81.3 billion, including a $26.7 billion vendor placement, bringing the overall amount to more than $100 billion. Trading-desk sources said market participants sold gold, copper, cryptocurrencies, Nvidia, and other AI proxy assets to raise funds for subscriptions. This account was consistent with market moves: gold fell below $3,800, copper dropped about 5%, and cryptocurrencies retreated across the board.

Third, the drag from the consumer sector was even more pronounced.

Every S&P 500 consumer discretionary stock was down by the afternoon. Strong consumer spending has been a central pillar of the U.S. economy’s resilience this year, and this signal heightened investor concerns about a slowdown in consumption.

Fourth, year-end profit-taking pressure.

Institutional investors, meanwhile, had their own calculations. The New York Times noted that despite the recent increase in market volatility, investors had still enjoyed substantial returns overall this year. Around Thanksgiving, traders tend to lock in profits because market liquidity contracts toward year-end, making it more difficult to execute trades at favorable prices.

Optimists Have Not Given Up

Goldman Sachs analyst Rich Privorotsky issued a warning that morning: “Today feels important.” He noted that institutions’ net exposure to technology stocks stood at about 18%, well below the sector’s 29% index weighting and near an extreme five-year underweight—meaning that as long as the market did not fall sharply, it could trigger a short squeeze driven by position rebuilding.

Direxion also said the market remained broadly positive about Anthropic’s IPO. Nvidia’s better-than-expected earnings and Anthropic’s successful listing together bolstered confidence that “the AI trade is not over.”

Looking ahead, the market’s attention is turning to the monthly options expiration on November 20. With a concentration of negative-gamma positions set to expire, it will be the next key window to watch. Risk Warning and Disclaimer

Markets involve risks, and investments should be made with caution. This article does not constitute personal investment advice, nor does it take into account the specific investment objectives, financial circumstances, or needs of individual users. Users should consider whether any opinions, views, or conclusions in this article are appropriate for their particular circumstances. Anyone investing on this basis does so at their own risk.

Source

Wallstreetcn