AI News

Is a nationwide "withdrawal" from Hongguo possible?

TMTPost · AGIUpdated Nov 16 19:11

AI summary

Hongguo short dramas have an average daily usage time of about 125 minutes, already surpassing Douyin and WeChat, and controversy surrounding "dumbing down" and "addiction" surged onto Weibo's trending searches around October 14. Among exam-preparation groups, repeatedly uninstalling and reinstalling has become the norm, and some have set up the "Shang'an Jieguo Mutual Aid Camp" for check-in supervision. The article also notes that although the entry threshold for AI short dramas has been lowered, the hit rate in the first quarter of this year was only 0.16%, and traffic-buying costs accounted for 70% to 90% of recharge revenue.

Body · AI translation

By Dao Zong You Li

Lately, there has been more and more controversy surrounding Hongguo.

Around October 14, multiple Hongguo-related topics surged onto Weibo's trending list, such as "Hongguo short dramas lower your IQ," "Whatever you do, don't download Hongguo short dramas," "What does Tencent plan to use to challenge Hongguo's nearly 200 million daily active users," "Hongguo short dramas are homogenized," "Hongguo short drama anti-addiction"...

Earlier still, Jia Zhangke, Wang Shuo and a host of other literary figures publicly stated that they were addicted to short dramas and short videos, triggering a collective "great lamentation" across the entire literary youth circle. In short, with the mobile internet having developed to this day, short drama apps represented by Hongguo have penetrated into the ranks of the entire population, and the trend is only intensifying.

According to statistics from a third-party data agency, in August 2026, among the top 50 apps in China ranked by monthly usage time, Hongguo short dramas averaged about 125 minutes per day, already surpassing Douyin's roughly 112 to 120 minutes and WeChat's roughly 82 to 90 minutes.

Seeing the situation develop from purely entertainment into vicious trends like "lowering IQ" and "addiction," a wave of "quitting" Hongguo has swept across social platforms. It is said that a post-00s student preparing for graduate school uninstalled Hongguo five times in a single month; others have spontaneously set up mutual-aid groups to supervise each other and fight addiction together.

But quitting Hongguo is easier said than done. Everyone wants to break free from the mindless pleasure brought by "thrill," yet the moment they have free time, they fall back in as before.

The "Hongguo Quitting War" in the civil service exam group: what we're fighting has never been just an app

It was almost midnight, and Lin Jing (pseudonym) stared at the "Install" button in the app store for a full three minutes. A pile of administrative aptitude test past papers and essay-writing materials was stacked on the desk, several highlighters of different colors were tossed in front of the tablet, and a "countdown to passing the exam" label was stuck on the wall. After hesitating for a long time, she still gave up on installing it.

Then, Lin Jing sent a screenshot to the group chat, signifying "today is another day of successfully resisting Hongguo."

Lin Jing, born in 1998, is an older candidate among those preparing for the civil service exam. Last year, she had just signed a "lifetime contract" with the leading pharmaceutical multinational where she worked. She had originally stopped worrying about the future the way her peers did, but soon medical reform, a hyper-competitive environment, a change of regional leadership... various factors sharply increased her work pressure.

So Lin Jing simply began preparing for the civil service exam.

Because she was studying while working, her already busy life became even more monotonous. At first, Hongguo was just "background noise" on her commute, then it slowly became a "brief relaxation" when she was tired of studying, and later, she could no longer remember how many times she had intended to scroll for ten minutes before starting her essay, only to look up from a domineering-CEO drama and find that she had written nothing but a title in her notebook.

This was the fifth time she had uninstalled Hongguo this month, because her mock administrative aptitude test score had dropped seven points from last time.

Lin Jing summed it up, and the triggers for each uninstall were much the same: a failed mock exam, discovering during review that she had wasted too much time, a surge of intense self-loathing after scrolling late at night... and the reason for reinstalling was always the same: just watch for a bit, balance work and rest.

The first uninstall lasted only three days.

Screenshot of daily group chat in the "Pass the Exam, Quit Hongguo Mutual Aid Camp," provided by Lin Jing

"I thought it was just my weak willpower." It wasn't until she saw more and more posts about "failed quitting" on social platforms that she realized she was not a special case. Among the high-pressure exam-prep groups for graduate school and civil service exams, "repeatedly uninstalling Hongguo" has almost become a collective symptom.

So Lin Jing simply set up a "quit Hongguo group."

At first, the group consisted of childhood friends who had grown up together; later, as people invited people and word spread, the membership expanded from 6 to more than a dozen, basically all exam-prep candidates. The group was ultimately named the "Pass the Exam, Quit Hongguo Mutual Aid Camp," and the rules were simple and blunt: post an uninstall screenshot as a daily check-in, ask the group to scold you when you can't resist, and report your study time for the day each evening.

Every morning, the group was filled with identical uninstall screenshots, with captions so uniform they felt like some kind of ritual:

"Day one of quitting today" "This time I'll definitely make it." By afternoon and late night, confessional messages would gradually emerge: "Sorry everyone, I installed it again" "I just uninstalled it half an hour ago, I'm really useless." Below would always follow a long string of agreement: "Me too" "+1, I just scrolled for an hour before I snapped out of it"...

After going back and forth, everyone began trying everything: some shared phone-locking software, some recommended feature phones, some simply deleted their accounts... They tried every method, with more failures than successes.

Last week, Lin Jing suddenly realized: they seemed to be fighting Hongguo, but in reality they were fighting the attention trap of an entire internet era. It is said that exam-prep candidates are one of the groups most addicted to Hongguo, because their behavioral patterns and emotional needs play right into Hongguo's hands.

First, it is a perfect fit for fragmented time. The rhythm of exam prep is high-pressure and broken up: focus on studying for fifty minutes, rest for ten. This ten-minute "relaxation gap" is exactly Hongguo's golden entry time.

Second, it precisely compensates for delayed gratification.

Exam prep is a battle with an extremely long feedback cycle, while what Hongguo offers is feedback in seconds. A thrill point every few seconds, an emotional resonance every few seconds—the brain instinctively avoids the dull pain of doing practice questions and turns to this low-cost, high-reward pleasure.

What's more interesting is that as the current group of civil service and public institution exam takers grows, more and more short dramas are incorporating this "era meme" into their plots.

For example, revenge dramas like "She Passed the Civil Service Exam and Her Whole Family Panicked" portray "passing the exam" as a trump card for a comeback; hit dramas like "You're a Civil Service Exam Instructor, How Did You Become a National Preceptor?" with 57.79 million effective plays package exam ability as a golden finger; and realistic dramas like "The Bully Passed the Civil Service Exam" turn the civil service exam into the skeleton of conflict, naturally carrying suspense, competition and room for reversals.

Compared with fabricated feuds among wealthy families, civil service exam short dramas come with an empathetic narrative, launching a targeted content hunt aimed squarely at exam-prep groups.

Right now, Hongguo is far more than just an entertainment app. For young people in the uphill phase of life, it is an emotional outlet amid high-pressure living, a social substitute during isolated exam prep, and one of the few pleasures that can be obtained instantly in the day-after-day tedium. They hate it for stealing their time, yet they depend on it for a breather.

On one side is a loose community held together by willpower and guilt; on the other, a team of professional product managers, algorithm engineers and content operators who study human weaknesses and design countless triggers and hooks with a single goal: to keep you there one more minute, and then one more minute.

This is not a fair contest.

Behind "quitting Hongguo" is a group of ordinary people trying to escape industrial-scale attention harvesting.

At 12:20 a.m., Lin Jing finally pressed the back button and tossed her phone to the other end of the bed.

She picked up her pen and looked again at the unfinished data-analysis question.

It took only 4 days to drag the literary youth off the pedestal: why despise lowbrow pleasure?

Wang Yuan (pseudonym) is Lin Jing's childhood friend and the only outlier in the "Quit Hongguo group."

She works as a finance staffer at a new-materials company. As the company's performance worsens by the day, she is currently following the trend of preparing for the civil service exam. She also follows the crowd in binge-watching dramas and in quitting... While the other members keep generating shame and guilt over their Hongguo addiction, she alone always exudes an undisguised, unconflicted sense of ease.

"Life is hard enough already—what's wrong with watching two episodes of short drama?" is a line she often repeats.

In Wang Yuan's eyes, the one even more "eccentric" than her is another childhood friend, Su Rui. Su Rui is widely recognized in their circle as the "ambassador of highbrow pleasure": on ordinary evenings after work she watches old films, on weekends she lights incense, brews tea and collects physical books; there is not a single short-video app on her phone, and her social media is nothing but poetry excerpts and film photography...

Before returning to their hometown for the National Day holiday, Wang Yuan made a bet with Lin Jing: within these seven days, she would drag this literary youth all the way to the bottom of the Hongguo pit.

"Even Jia Zhangke couldn't avoid it—all you literary youths, sink for me," she declared in the group chat.

The annual childhood-friends gathering was held at a café in the county town. Lin Jing curled up on the sofa scrolling Hongguo, Wang Yuan was forwarding an AI orange-cat short video, and only Su Rui sat across from them rolling her eyes. She even advised the two exam preppers: "You two need focus to begin with, yet you scroll this every day—the more you scroll, the less you can settle down to do questions."

Lin Jing nodded in agreement, then went right back to scrolling.

Su Rui criticized it all the way, from the alienating logic of algorithms to the barrenness of cultural fast food, citing widely and arguing rigorously. Wang Yuan couldn't take it anymore and thrust her phone in front of Su Rui's eyes, where an AI calico cat was clawing at the fridge door: "Look, it can open the freezer and get ice cream—as smart as you."

Su Rui rolled her eyes again.

On the second day of the holiday, the three went to make pottery. Wang Yuan found a historical short drama and deliberately played it aloud next to Su Rui. The opening lines of ancient-style dialogue were deep and weighty, the score textured. Suddenly Su Rui blurted out: "This voice—sounds like a voice actor I know."

Wang Yuan sent Su Rui a whole batch of hit historical short dramas—"Qin Shi Huang: I Have a Full All-Star Cast of Huaxia," "Armed Into the Song Dynasty," "Tales of the Myriad Demon Scrolls"... The group chat instantly turned into Su Rui's "nitpicking scene" over short dramas: costume and artifact research, historical narrative fidelity, plot logic and values... every thrill point landed squarely on her aesthetic minefield.

A crack opened in the literary youth's world, and Su Rui sent a link: "This Zhuge Liang model feels so right!"

Chat screenshot provided by Wang Yuan

Su Rui watched a fantasy short drama with satirical undertones until midnight.

The "literary youth defense-breaking plan" originally set for seven days was fully won by Wang Yuan in only four.

This seems to be exactly the cleverness of how short dramas hunt users: it does not forcibly drag you down from your aesthetic high ground; instead, it uses thrill-point logic to raise the content up to your high ground. Once content puts on the aesthetic clothing you know and approve of, you can no longer push it away with the standard of "taste."

Before algorithms, everyone is equal. Content is comprehensively downgraded, and there is no longer a chain of contempt in the world.

Wang Yuan does not understand this collective narrative of the moment: since when was pleasure divided into strict tiers? Those zero-threshold, low-cost, tiny joys are uniformly labeled "lowbrow," pushed to the opposite side of self-discipline and growth, and turned into "dumbing-down" behavior that anyone can point at.

In Wang Yuan's view, this moral trial of "lowbrow pleasure" itself carries an arrogance detached from the context of survival.

Young people today are in an all-around involutionary survival system: the terrifying admission ratios of the civil service exam track, KPIs in the workplace, and even leisure is bound to the utilitarian goal of "self-improvement"... But so-called "highbrow pleasure"—art exhibitions, travel recharging, deep cultivation of hobbies—all of these require a threshold.

In the northern third-tier city where Wang Yuan lives, a theater ticket easily costs over a hundred yuan and a movie dozens, while Hongguo costs only a few seconds of ads.

During the National Day holiday, she had also planned to put down her phone and travel. But over a thousand yuan in travel, accommodation, tickets and food... combined with the layoff and pay-cut plans widely rumored at her company, she ultimately chose to work overtime voluntarily. Fortunately, the company's holiday overtime subsidy has not yet been canceled.

A "2026 Holiday Travel Survey Results Feedback" from one locality shows that residents prioritize cost-effectiveness when traveling, with mid-range spending the absolute mainstream. Among the main considerations in choosing a destination, affordable prices (18.33%) beat scenic features (15.83%), and for reasons not to travel, high costs account for 17.06%.

Giving up travel and wallowing in Hongguo has already gathered from scattered individual choices into a holiday trend.

On October 14, a Shangguan News reporter checked social platforms and found that many netizens had posted their recent phone screen time, with their average daily use of Hongguo short dramas exceeding 10 hours. If pleasure must be redeemed against economic cost, countless ordinary people will probably keep choosing Hongguo.

Wang Yuan feels she has already seen through the essence of the happiness hierarchy, even though she too wants to "quit" Hongguo.

As I keep quitting, I've started wanting to make AI short dramas too: Isn't 50,000 yuan enough?

In the "Quit Hongguo group," apart from Lin Jing, the person most deeply addicted to Hongguo is Zhang Heng. The two of them are also the ones calling for a group to "quit" together.

Zhang Heng runs a phone shop in his hometown county. Over the past two years, as the offline market for 3C products has grown increasingly sluggish, his shop has been in a state of half-day open, half-day idle. Spurred on by several childhood friends all preparing for civil service exams, he also bought several sets of textbooks and flips through them at the shop in his spare time.

Since the start of this year, Hongguo short dramas have gradually replaced work, life, and family to become the top topic across the whole childhood-friends group chat.

Zhang Heng summed it up:

Lin Jing likes domineering-CEO sweet romance, Wang Yuan likes child-rearing healing stories, and two others—one likes thriller suspense, one likes male-oriented comeback tales. Even Su Rui, the newest convert, has precisely found her own "channel": historical power struggles... Everyone guards their own "content lane," together forming a typical consumption picture of the short-drama industry.

This forms a striking generational contrast with the long-video consumption patterns of a few years ago.

Previously, the group's long-video membership accounts were in a state of "shared circulation"—you used mine, I used yours, with each person paying for one of iQIYI, Youku, Tencent Video, and Mango TV. But this year, when Zhang Heng happened to log into his Tencent Video account, he found that in the device login list, only Su Rui's record was still updating.

Whether that record will continue updating in the future is a question.

Zhang Heng had only an entertainment attitude toward short dramas—until stories spread everywhere of the "grassroots myth" of AI animated dramas, where one person with a few computers produces a hit with billions of views... In July, he came across a report about a post-95 couple from Bazhong, Sichuan, whose works had accumulated over 4.1 billion views.

What really moved him was a story he heard at a class reunion before National Day.

A boss in the building-materials business in a neighboring county, who like him was worrying about store traffic shrinking year after year, hired two young people this year to make county-themed AI short dramas, specifically filming stories of family squabbles and small-town comebacks, with plans to take on custom ads from car dealerships and furniture stores in the future.

In an instant, the idea of a "second startup" sprouted in Zhang Heng's mind.

In the era of live-action short dramas, Zhang Heng assumed making short dramas was the business of MCNs and professional teams. Writing scripts, finding actors, shooting on location, doing post-production—every link required real money. But the spread of AI video-generation tools has lowered this industry threshold dramatically, becoming the biggest generational dividend for amateurs entering the field.

He had run a phone shop for five or six years, had handled every mass-market digital product, and learned software quickly. More importantly, he had written novels on the Qidian website in college, and had been binge-watching short dramas for nearly a year—what plots keep people hooked, what twists hit hardest, he could count seven or eight types with his eyes closed.

He said: "If you can't beat them, join them."

Soon, the "Quit Hongguo group" was in an uproar. Compared with those clapping in support, the majority poured cold water.

Lin Jing sent an industry research report. In the first half of this year, more than 221,900 new AI short dramas launched across the internet, with over 500,000 practitioners; only about one in every 200 works becomes a hit, and if 50 million views is the break-even line, fewer than 1.3% of them recoup their costs.

Lin Jing asked him a crucial question: "What's your budget?"

For an instant the group fell silent. A few minutes later, Su Rui replied: "Wash up and go to sleep, work tomorrow."

The group chat screenshot was provided by Lin Jing.

But Zhang Heng still refused to give up, sharing his plan in the group from time to time—after all, there are few booming industries left in the market. His phone shop had long been in a half-dead state. In his plan, the annual budget of 50,000 yuan was split into three parts:

The first part is a one-time hardware investment, capped at 8,000 yuan. The office computer in the shop was already a high-spec machine built up from phone repair work; add a professional-grade graphics card and a capture card. The second part is the year's tool and material costs, strictly controlled within 12,000 yuan, averaging exactly 1,000 per month.

The remaining 30,000 yuan is his reserved traffic-testing and risk contingency fund.

At present, Zhang Heng has planned to convert the balcony at home into a mini studio, though half a month has passed and the plan has yet to materialize.

Zhang Heng's preparatory studio and short-drama viewing stand

As Lin Jing and the others said, the more Zhang Heng researched, the more he felt he had been overly optimistic about this industry—especially traffic-buying costs.

It is reported that traffic-buying fees are the largest part of short-drama costs, usually accounting for 70% to 90% of recharge revenue. For a hit drama with over 100 million yuan in recharges, traffic-buying costs often reach 60 to 80 million yuan; after deducting production costs and various revenue shares, actual profit may be only a few million yuan.

Meanwhile, according to the National Radio and Television Administration, in the first quarter of this year, the hit rate for AI short dramas was only 0.16%—meaning that for every 635 AI short dramas launched, barely one work exceeds 100 million views; 64% of works have fewer than 1 million views, unable to even cover computing costs.

What made Zhang Heng begin to back off even more was another set of data: according to DataEye's Juchacha data, the revenue per thousand views from traffic-buying for AI short dramas has already halved year-on-year to 15–30 yuan, and the revenue side is shrinking in tandem. A year ago, the revenue per ten thousand views for AI short dramas was still between 30 and 100 yuan; now it has been halved to 5–10 yuan.

Forget it—he might as well keep selling phones.

Postscript

The October night wind sweeps across the streets and alleys of the north and along the windowsills of office buildings, with cold phone light glimmering in dots everywhere.

Algorithms are still iterating, content is still being mass-produced, some people are still withdrawing, some have already joined in, and some are forever relaxed.

No one is a true winner, and no one has completely lost. Life is still moving forward, and people ultimately have to, amid the long delay of gratification, occasionally catch that little bit of sweetness that can be touched without effort. Grand industrial narratives press down on ordinary people, creating countless lingering disappointments.

Source

TMTPost · AGI