Who Is Fooling Ordinary People into Entering the AI Comic Drama Market?
Wenyu Xiansheng, a publication under TMTPost, published an article reviewing the wealth-creation narrative surrounding AI comic dramas, pointing out that the proportion of works that actually recoup their costs is very low. Data from the DataEye Research Institute shows that in the first half of this year, 221,900 new AI dramas and comic dramas were added on the Douyin platform, with only 1,055 surpassing 100 million views, accounting for about 0.48%; using 50 million views as the break-even line, 2,886 works met the threshold, accounting for about 1.3%. The article also mentions that revenue per ten thousand views dropped from over 100 yuan to 30 to 50 yuan, and names training courses, franchise agencies, and project intermediaries as the main drivers.
Why read this
AI score 52
The article uses viewership distribution, declining per-ten-thousand-views revenue, and training and franchise cases to break down the real revenue structure behind the wealth-creation narrative of AI comic dramas.
Topics
Body · AI translation
By Wen | Wenyu Xiansheng
I don't know if you've noticed, but recently, hot searches about how popular AI comic dramas are, how much money they make, and how they crush live-action dramas keep popping up from time to time. Clicking in, you often find a round of hype about AI comic dramas: someone got over a hundred million views with a single work, someone broke a million in revenue with AI comic dramas, and some even achieved financial freedom in just a few months.
One comeback story after another keeps appearing, as if as long as you seize this trend, ordinary people can also usher in a chance to change their fate.
And accompanying these success stories are more and more ads for AI comic drama training and franchising. From zero-foundation introductions to quick order-taking, from low-cost entrepreneurship to stable income, all kinds of institutions are sending ordinary people one signal: now is exactly the right time to enter.
01 Can everyone get a piece of the pie?
First, look at overall market performance. According to DataEye Research Institute data, in the first half of this year, 221,900 new AI dramas and comic dramas were added on the Douyin side, of which only 1,055 works broke 100 million views, accounting for about 0.48%. If DataEye's set 50 million views is used as the break-even reference line, only 2,886 works reached that scale, accounting for about 1.3%. While a large number of works flood into the market, those that can truly recoup their costs are still a minority.
As for the actual income the public cares about most, the situation is likewise not optimistic.
According to feedback from practitioners, since the beginning of this year, playback revenue for AI comic dramas has been falling rapidly. A person in charge of an AI comic drama company revealed in an interview with China Newsweek that previously, a work with over 100 million views earned more than 100 yuan per 10,000 views; but by May this year, it had dropped to 30 to 50 yuan. Now another half year has passed, and the situation is even less optimistic.
For individual creators, actual income may be even lower. Creator Xingyu Shinyo once shared on Xiaohongshu her experience of hand-making an AI comic drama: "I Became My Father Emperor's Strongest Mouthpiece," which she independently produced, has 12 episodes in total, with a production cost of 1,715 yuan. One month after launch, its popularity value reached 14.85 million, and actual views exceeded 49,000, yet the income was only 19.64 yuan, with revenue of only 3.97 yuan per 10,000 views. It can be seen that for individual creators lacking funds and experience, it is not easy to recoup costs with a single work.
Even if the production problem is solved, acquiring traffic is also an unavoidable issue.
Recently, Fu Peng, an economist at Xinhuo Group, publicly pointed out that in the past three months, AI comic dramas have almost all been losing money. According to his estimate, if one chooses to run traffic oneself, the cost of buying traffic accounts for about 80% to 90% of total costs, computing power costs about 10%, and after adding hardware depreciation, the profit ultimately left by the project is only about 5%.
He even compared creators to "digital tenant farmers" working for platforms, saying that AI, as a new productive force, although it has greatly improved content production efficiency, has not changed the old logic of platform bidding distribution and benefit allocation. The costs saved on the production side are quickly swallowed up by traffic buying, and the higher the production efficiency, the thinner the return per unit of content.
Of course, the high traffic-buying costs Fu Peng mentioned mainly correspond to the business model in which one must bear the cost of buying traffic oneself, and do not fully apply to distribution systems such as Fanqie. Take Fanqie's Changdu content distribution platform as an example: after obtaining IP authorization, creators only need to deliver the finished film, while distributors independently select products, spend money on traffic, and rely on conversion from placements to get a share.
But this does not mean producers can completely escape the uncertainty of traffic and revenue. Whether a work can obtain platform resources, how much traffic it can get after launch, and how much revenue it can ultimately share are still affected by content quality, platform project screening, traffic distribution, and revenue-sharing rules.
Take the copyright investment model as an example. The platform rates projects based on the script outline, character settings, planning proposal, and demo submitted by the production team, and high-quality IP is also only opened in a targeted way to a small number of top production parties. Hongguo's previously launched "Guoran Plan" set up a clear project screening mechanism. In AI script cooperation, Hongguo also set different minimum guarantee policies according to content rating. According to the latest policy announced on November 12, the minimum guarantee for S-level AI scripts is 15,000 yuan, A-level scripts have no minimum guarantee, and B-level scripts are not accepted for cooperation.
Therefore, whether the work itself can perform is also a hard threshold. The revenue-sharing ratios differ among works of different quality. Premium dramas with more polished scenes and greater production investment can earn several times, or even more than, the revenue per 10,000 views of ordinary lower-tier works.
Recently, Xiao Guo Gege, creator of the hit short drama "Anhui Carpenter," also confirmed this in a conversation with media person Pan Luan. He gave an example, saying that his lower-tier drama earned only 1.5 yuan per 10,000 views, while a premium drama could reach 12 yuan, an 8-fold difference. This also shows that even for works by the same person, entering the same platform and using similar distribution methods, revenue performance can differ vastly.
As for whether ordinary people should enter the pit, he also gave specific advice: people with experience in shooting, editing, self-media, or novel promotion posts can try on a small scale, while people with no relevant experience at all should not participate blindly.
This view coincides with that of Zhang Hansheng, chief planner of "Armed Into Song." In his view, AI equality is only equality of access to models; a lower technical threshold does not mean the creative threshold has disappeared. To make better works, the key still lies in content and creative thinking. Because "AI itself has no emotions; much patriotism, affection, and emotion need to be endowed by creators." He also reminded people not to package AI comic dramas as a business where signing up for a class can produce a hit and everyone can make money.
Ultimately, the windfalls that ordinary people see falling from the sky are never actually that simple.
Recently, the story of Xiao Tianle, a junior at Soochow University who earned more than 3 million yuan in revenue from AI comic dramas, trended on social media. But a closer look at his entrepreneurial experience reveals that behind this achievement lies continuous content production and the accumulation of commercial business. In less than a year, his team has produced hundreds of comic dramas, of which only one is a genuine breakout hit. In addition, his team also takes on commercial orders for comic dramas, so the income does not come solely from platform revenue sharing.
02 Who is misleading ordinary people into entering the market?
The ones who value this business most are clearly the training institutions. Everyone has probably seen AI comic drama training ads on social platforms or short-video platforms, ranging from 9.9-yuan introductory courses to systematic training costing thousands or even tens of thousands of yuan, with highly similar promotional rhetoric: even people with zero foundation can learn it, master the production process in three days, start taking orders and making money within a week, with no need for a professional team or film and television experience.
But in reality, learning the basic operations of AI tools and having independent production capability are two different things. From image generation and video generation to script adaptation and shot design, all require long-term practice and repeated trial and error. Short-term training may teach students some basic operations, but it is hard to guarantee that they can independently complete works, let alone take orders and make money from it. Many people who buy these AI courses end up paying an IQ tax to themselves.
Second are franchise recruitment and system service providers. Compared with selling courses, these institutions go a step further, directly packaging AI comic dramas as a business that can be franchised: buy the production system, pay the franchise fee, and with so-called platform resources and stable orders, you can have your own AI comic drama studio.
According to Wenyu Xiansheng, a consumer in Hubei was once charged 59,800 yuan by a network company in Jinan under the name of "regional agency" to purchase an AI comic drama production system. The other party promised that the operation could be learned in half an hour and that one could also earn commissions by developing sub-agents. But after signing the contract, he found that the so-called self-developed system was actually just public resources available online, and the promised regional exclusive agency could not be delivered.
For these institutions, what really matters is selling the production system, franchise qualifications and computing power packages.
In addition, there are related MCNs and project intermediaries. AI comic drama production requires a large amount of manpower, and some companies recruit individual creators and small studios to take on orders. Normal project cooperation itself is not a problem, but some intermediaries recruit creators under the banner of platform orders, guaranteed returns and internal resources, then charge computing power fees and deposits, or transfer production costs and rework risks to individuals through layer upon layer of subcontracting. For inexperienced creators, even if they get orders, they may find that the income is not enough to cover production costs.
Beyond these business models, there is also the pushing from platforms, tool vendors and industry players. Platforms need more content, tool vendors want to expand the scale of use of models and computing power, production companies need capacity, and local governments are also promoting the implementation of related industries. Together, these factors have raised the industry's heat and continuously given AI comic dramas new growth imaginings.
Early live-action short dramas attracted a large number of teams to enter the market thanks to short production cycles, low costs and quick returns. But as market supply increased, it became difficult to form a competitive advantage by relying solely on low cost and mass production, and content quality and traffic acquisition gradually became important factors determining a work's performance. The same is true of AI comic dramas: technological progress has greatly reduced the production cost of a work, enabling more individuals and teams to enter the market at the same time, and content supply has rapidly increased accordingly.
It can be seen that what AI comic dramas are going through is not just a period of technological dividend, but a process from low-threshold production to fierce market competition. As the cost advantage of production is gradually diluted, creators will ultimately have to return to the content itself and solve the problems of traffic acquisition and commercial monetization.
On July 31, the National Radio and Television Administration issued the "Measures for the Administration of the Development of Micro Short Dramas," making clear that micro short dramas generated and produced using AI technology shall add prompt labels in accordance with regulations. On November 6, the NRTA again deployed a new round of special governance of micro short dramas, targeting problems such as uneven quality, vulgarization and homogenization of AI micro short dramas, as well as face theft and voice theft.
"Armed Into Song" had a rather controversial detail. Some viewers noticed that starting from the third season, the names of historical regimes originally in the drama, such as the Northern Song, Western Xia, Liao and Jin, were changed to "Southern Territory" (Northern Song), "Western Territory" (Western Xia), "Northern Territory" (Liao) and "Eastern Territory" (Jin), and some city names were also changed. A time-travel story originally about Northern Song history suddenly took on a bit of an alternate fantasy drama flavor, and many viewers even joked that they thought it was going to become "Game of Thrones."
Although the creators did not publicly explain the specific reason for the renaming, chief planner Zhang Hansheng once said in an interview that the team needed to consider review red lines when creating and try to adapt while respecting the original work as much as possible. For AI comic drama creators, in addition to production and market competition, content compliance is also an issue that must be considered in advance.
The development of the industry needs confidence and also more participants. But what is truly worth being vigilant about is that some people only show ordinary people low costs and high returns while deliberately downplaying market competition, operational risks and compliance responsibilities, making them mistakenly believe that as long as they learn production, they can easily share in the industry's dividends, and in the end they spend money for nothing. That is somewhat unethical.
03 Conclusion
But technology lowering the production threshold does not mean a work can move the audience. If hot searches are flooded with revenue myths and wealth stories while truly good works fail to keep up, it will only lead more people to enter with the wrong expectations. When the hype fades, what remains may be the disappointment of creators, and it will also overdraft the audience's confidence in this emerging content form.
Compared with blindly following traffic trends, a love for stories should be the starting point for creators to enter the market. Only when creators are willing to calm down and tell stories, and audiences are willing to stay for good works, can this industry truly usher in spring.