US Senator Asks Google to Let Schools Disable AI Features in Search Engine
US Senator Markey sent a letter to Google, asking it to allow schools to disable AI features in Search without affecting students' use of the search engine. Google said that AI Overviews and AI Mode are deeply integrated with the search engine and cannot be disabled separately, and said it is making adjustments so that schools can more easily control students' access to AI services. Markey also asked Google to submit, by the end of this month, research on the impact of search AI features on student safety and learning outcomes.
Why read this
AI score 62
The incident presents a direct conflict between schools' demand for control and Google's product integration, and offers an observable view of the boundaries of authority when AI features enter educational settings.
Topics
Body · AI translation
However, Google says that if schools want students to continue using the search engine for queries, they cannot turn off the artificial intelligence features in Search.
Google explained that this is because tools such as AI Overviews and AI Mode are already "deeply integrated" with the search engine. Among them, AI Mode is a chatbot-like feature, while AI Overviews can automatically generate summaries of search results.
In addition, Google will also launch a student AI chat feature called "Guided Learning," aimed at helping students complete their studies while reducing the use of artificial intelligence to cheat.
At present, there is growing public concern that chatbots may hinder students' learning and pose risks to children's mental health, and the tech industry is therefore facing greater public pressure.
Google's announcement last week drew criticism from some politicians and nonprofit organizations. They believe that Google's insistence on retaining AI features in the search engine is undermining schools' ability to independently set teaching and safety policies for students.
In the letter, Markey said: "Despite growing concerns about the risks AI chatbots pose to minors, Google is using its dominance in the education technology sector to force AI chatbots on children and teenagers, without regard to whether schools consider the technology safe."
He added: "This is not offering a choice; it is issuing an ultimatum to schools and effectively forcing them to enable generative artificial intelligence."
Google said last week that the adjustments the company is implementing will make it easier for schools to control students' access to AI services.
Google also said that its new AI feature for schools, "Guided Learning," will help students think through and solve problems step by step rather than directly providing answers.
Markey's letter also cited a report from August of this year. The report said that for schools that had already enabled the Gemini chatbot, Google had automatically turned on AI features in Google Classroom for their kindergarten through 12th grade (K-12) students. Google Classroom is an application used to assign and manage schoolwork.
Google now plans to turn off these features.
In the letter, Markey asked whether Google would change its position and allow schools to turn off AI features in Search without affecting students' use of the search engine.
He also asked Google to explain whether it is technically possible for K-12 students logged into school Google accounts to receive search results that do not contain AI-generated answers or guidance content.
In addition, Markey demanded that Google submit, by the end of this month, all relevant research the company has conducted on the impact of search engine AI features on student safety and learning outcomes.
AI Trends