Thomas Wolf Explains Two Reasons for Signing a Statement Criticizing Anthropic
Thomas Wolf said that although he does not fully agree with the wording of the statement, he decided to sign it because of concerns about Anthropic's transparency and the concentration of power. He believes Anthropic's growing influence must be matched by greater transparency and openness. He has also heard from entrepreneurs, executives, and researchers who are afraid to voice their concerns publicly for fear of harming their career prospects or losing access to models.
Why read this
AI score 60
Thomas Wolf explains his reasons for signing from the perspectives of transparency and the concentration of power, while also highlighting the real pressure industry insiders face over potential impacts on their careers and access to models.
Topics
View original postNumerous AI safety groups told us privately they agreed with this statement, yet felt unable to sign without risking relationships or future funding. Anthropic has almost, but not entirely, captured the ecosystem meant to hold it accountable.
View original
Numerous AI safety groups told us privately they agreed with this statement, yet felt unable to sign without risking relationships or future funding. Anthropic has almost, but not entirely, captured the ecosystem meant to hold it accountable.
Body
I'm featured quite visibly on Dan's letter, so it's probably good that I briefly explain why I signed while having friends at Anthropic and a lot of respect for them in general.
I don't fully agree with the wording. I wouldn't have used "reckless", and I didn't know the name of the statement when I signed, which isn't my style. But I agree with the underlying sentiment and decided to sign for two reasons.
First, Anthropic is currently on track to be the most powerful company on earth (and for good reasons, like the quality of the team and product). This level of impact on the world will require a degree of transparency and openness close to, or maybe even higher than, that of a sovereign government, and I'm worried they are not currently on track to reach it. It's a version of "with great power comes great responsibility", applied to social responsibility toward everyone using and impacted by your products.
Second, Dan mentions safety groups who felt unable to sign. I heard the same thing directly from a different crowd: entrepreneurs, executives and researchers who agreed with the concerns but were afraid of consequences for their careers or their access to models. Whether or not that fear is justified, I think it's a first example of the problem above, and a worrying early signal about concentration of power in itself.
I'd genuinely like to be proven wrong on both points, and I think Anthropic has the people to do it.
AI Trends