Can Data Center Waste Heat Warm a Small North Carolina Town?
The town of Enfield, North Carolina, is negotiating a community benefits agreement with Quiet Data Centers, requiring the proposed 100,000-square-foot, 88-megawatt data center to fund a $16.2 million clean energy plan and connect to a planned thermal energy network, using its excess heat to warm the entire town. If realized, this would be the first case in the United States of a data center connecting to such a system. Quiet Chief Development Officer Brendan Morris confirmed that negotiations are still ongoing and that all goals are on the table.
Body
Could a data center’s waste heat warm a North Carolina town?
Enfield wants a proposed data center to fund community benefits, including a thermal energy network that would use its excess heat — it’d be a first for the U.S.
By Elizabeth Ouzts
Servers at a Facebook data center in Forest City, North Carolina (Rainier Ehrhardt/Getty Images)
In the Carolinas, Ohio, Texas, and many other states, Democrats routed incumbent Republicans in this month’s elections at least in part because voters fear an onslaught of AI data centers — the massive computer warehouses that threaten to suck up water supplies, increase climate and air pollution, and drive up energy costs.
Voters didn’t just take their anger out on politicians. In red and blue areas alike, they also approved dozens of ballot measures pausing or restricting data centers, adding to the over 450 moratoriums already in place across the country.
The backlash has left state and local leaders grappling with how to put guardrails on the facilities and ensure they benefit nearby communities.
A forthcoming deal between a data center and Enfield, North Carolina — an overwhelmingly poor, majority Black town of 2,000 — could offer a groundbreaking example of what such development might look like.
For years, Enfield leaders and their allies have been working toward a clean energy vision that includes a solar farm to supply residents with power, a new substation to help distribute those renewable electrons, and a thermal energy network — a shallow form of geothermal that could replace inefficient water heating, space heating, and cooling. But they’ve faced a dearth of funding and fierce policy headwinds under President Donald Trump.
Then, this summer, Halifax County, where Enfield sits, announced it was selling property to Wyoming-based Quiet Data Centers, a land development firm, for a 100,000 square-foot facility. The industrial site is 2 miles outside the town but needs to tap into its wastewater systems.
For Enfield Mayor Mondale Robinson, that presented a bargaining opportunity. Now, he and top officials from Quiet are negotiating a community benefits agreement, a legally binding document that ties developers to certain benchmarks. Among other commitments, Robinson wants the company to fund the entire $16.2 million clean energy plan.
What’s more, he wants the data center to join the thermal energy network, which could provide a surge of excess heat to meet the whole town’s needs. If the plans come to fruition, it would be the first time in the U.S. that a data center has connected to such a system.
Duke University student Arka Solanki explains how a nearby data center could connect to a planned thermal energy network at a community event in Enfield, North Carolina, in September. (Elizabeth Ouzts/Canary Media)
Brendan Morris, Quiet’s chief development officer, confirmed to Canary Media that the discussions were ongoing and that all of Enfield’s aims were on the table. “I think things are possible,” he said. “We’re new to this community and new to the county. We look around and see how a new business and a new data center coming into the area can make a positive impact.”
Robinson, a self-proclaimed progressive, acknowledges that the midterms were a rebuke of the tech sector’s buildout. “Everybody should be against dirty data centers,” he said. But he believes the not-in-my-backyard approach has too often stuck communities like Enfield with polluting projects rejected by wealthier areas. That’s why he wants a data center that’s built sustainably and with community input. “There’s nothing progressive about saying we are against something, without saying what we are for,” he added.
A cheap, quiet option for cooling data centers
A year ago, Lancaster, Pennsylvania, became the first local government in the country to sign a community benefits agreement with a data center project, according to researchers at the World Resources Institute. The agreements have long been used for other types of developments, from manufacturing plants to solar farms, said Danielle Riedl, research associate at the nonprofit.
“But now, of course, the conversation — seemingly everywhere — is focused on data center development,” she said. Still, the agreements are no silver bullets. “You really want to see CBAs as one tool, together with zoning policies, development agreements, and other accountability mechanisms.”
In Halifax County, Quiet has pledged to mitigate some common data center complaints. At a public meeting this summer, the company said the 88-megawatt facility will plug into the Dominion Energy grid on its own dime and pay for all the electricity it needs, according to the local news outlet RRSpin. It will run backup generators for no more than 30 minutes a month, on average, unless there is an outage.
But the company also has to alleviate the immense heat generated by racks of computers inside the facility. And while Quiet has pledged to use closed-loop cooling — a less-water-intensive process than sending waste heat to cooling towers, where water then evaporates — the technology is expensive and noisy.
That’s where the thermal energy network comes in. The system is essentially a network of ground-source heat pumps. They’re analogous to air-source heat pumps, but move heat between the buildings and the earth rather than the outside air, thanks to a water-based solution that flows through a system of buried pipes.
Some data centers in Europe are already plugged into such systems as a way to release excess heat. The same technology could be used in Enfield, providing cooling without the noise and at less cost, said Eric Bosworth, a pioneer on utility-run thermal energy networks who runs his own consultancy called Thermal Energy Insights.
“It gives a layer of resiliency, and it’s going to save them money on cooling, too,” Bosworth said, referring to Quiet. “Every [unit] of heat that they send to the network is going to be cheaper than putting it up through their chillers.”
The nonprofit Enfield Energy Futures won a seed grant earlier this year to design the thermal energy network. But receiving funding from Quiet for the geothermal project — and the entire clean energy plan — would be game-changing.
A transparent, robust community benefits agreement with Quiet, said William Munn, Enfield Energy Futures executive director, would be “an incredible opportunity to take some of this unfettered wealth and set Enfield on course to take care of itself, make decisions for itself, and to be able to grow and sustain itself for the long term.”
The data center’s participation in the thermal energy network would be a boon in wintertime, when residents face extreme utility bills of $500 a month or more. During the region’s sweltering summers, Quiet’s excess heat could prove more challenging to handle.
“There’s no free lunch in physics,” Bosworth said. Solutions could include disconnecting the data center from the network or installing a technology called absorption chillers. “You’re essentially using a chemical reagent to produce cooling from waste heat. So, you could put in one of those systems and continue to harvest heat through the summer months, and benefit the network with cooling.”
Workers drill cores in Enfield, North Carolina, so that researchers can assess heat and soil properties for a thermal energy network. (Brian McAdoo)
As part of the seed grant, Brian McAdoo, associate professor at Duke University’s Nicholas School of the Environment, and his students have already been testing heat levels and soil properties to fine-tune specs for the network. Now, his team is also reworking the system plan for the potential addition of the data center.
“One possible way of getting rid of heat from a data center would be through groundwater,” McAdoo said. “Since we have so much water in the coastal plain sediments, if you put heat in one place, it can take that heat and move it.”
McAdoo will weigh all the options with Morris and the rest of the Quiet team. “We’re going to look at the plumbing. We’re going to look at the mechanical. We’re going to look at the heat that’s being produced,” Morris said. “Every climate is different. North Carolina is different than North Dakota, which is different than Helsinki. That’ll give us the parameters to go back to Enfield.”
The research and design work is time-consuming, part of why a final community benefits agreement, if it materializes, is likely still weeks, or even months, away.
“Rushing to get something on the books that is incomplete does a disservice to what the data center may be able to offer our community, but it also does a disservice to our residents,” Mayor Robinson said. “I don’t think any of us are living up to our full potential by signing agreements before things are completely understood.”
This signup form requires necessary cookies.
Elizabeth Ouzts is a contributing reporter at Canary Media who covers North Carolina and Virginia.