Chamath Says in Ten Years of Hardcore Breakthroughs in Silicon Valley, Only Musk Has Delivered
Silicon Valley investor Chamath Palihapitiya said in an interview that over the past decade there have been almost no truly impressive hardcore technological breakthroughs in Silicon Valley; apart from Musk's success with reusable rockets, a global satellite communications network, and electric vehicles, the main contributions of other top talent have been AirPods and Instagram short videos. He believes this points to a problem with where resources and talent flow in the tech industry: a large number of top minds are rushing toward ad optimization, recommendation algorithms, and user time spent, rather than difficult problems in the physical world. He also acknowledged that AI large models, chips, biotech, and cloud computing infrastructure are major advances of the past decade, but that this passage focuses on hard breakthroughs in the physical world.
Topics
View original postHonestly, spending hundreds of thousands to attend business school for two years is really not as good as repeatedly watching this entrepreneurial sharing session that Jensen Huang gave in a Stanford classroom 15 years ago. Every bit of business intuition Lao Huang explained to the Stanford students has been proven true one by one when viewed today, and its value is even higher than two years of an MBA. Many people think that business leaders start companies relying on a superpower that can predict the future, but in 2009, in his first class at Stanford, Lao Huang shattered that filter. In 1993, when he had just wanted to make 3D game chips, an investor on Sand Hill Road told him to his face that there was simply no video game market at all, and even his own mother, after hearing about it, urged him, why don't you go find a proper job. This 4-minute-23-second video is the first episode of the entire classic lecture. I have carefully re-edited the Chinese and English bilingual subtitles, and I suggest every brother who is looking for direction or has been poured cold water on by the people around him watch it completely three times. What moved me most in the whole video is that right at the start he disenchanted the lofty word "vision." He said that so-called vision is actually perspective: the way you see the world is different from others, and everyone can have this pair of glasses. Back in 1993, computers were still using Windows 3.1, and the fastest processor in the world was only 66 MHz. He himself joked that today you wouldn't even stuff this kind of chip into sneakers. In the eyes of investors and elders at the time, computers were for office work, and spending heavily to make workstation-level 3D graphics technology cheap for gaming was simply not doing proper work. But Lao Huang and his group happened to be the first generation raised alongside video games. The joy and explosive power of games were common sense to them that needed no proof. Others could not see it simply because the previous generation did not have this pair of glasses. To be honest, doing AI, products, and content today follows exactly the same logic. The models and tools everyone has now are becoming more and more similar. The truly uncopyable moat has never been writing a few more lines of prompts, but rather those unique perspectives from your past life experience that you think are obviously true while the people around you find strange or unimportant. Vision has never been some divine power to stand on a mountaintop and look down on the whole world. It is whether you dare to take your own different pair of glasses seriously, and whether you are willing, when others urge you to find a proper job, to grit your teeth and see the path through.
View original
说真的,花几十万去读两年商学院,真不如把黄仁勋15 年前在斯坦福教室里的这段创业分享反复刷几遍,老黄给斯坦福学生讲出来的每一句商业直觉,放到今天看全都被一一印证了,含金量比上两年 MBA 还顶。 很多人以为商业大佬创业靠的是能预测未来的超能力,但 2009 年老黄在斯坦福讲的第一堂课就把这层滤镜撕碎了,1 993 年他刚想做 3D 游戏芯片的时候,沙丘路的投资人当面跟他说根本没有电子游戏这个市场,连他亲妈听完都劝他,你干嘛不去找份正经工作。 这期 4 分 23 秒的视频是整场经典讲座的第 1 集,我重新精校了中英双语字幕,建议每个正在找方向、或者被周围人泼冷水的兄弟都完整看三遍。 整条视频最打动我的地方,是他一上来就把远见这个高大上的词给祛魅了,他说所谓远见,其实就是视角,你看世界的方式和别人不一样,而这副眼镜每个人都可以有。 1993 年那会儿电脑还在用 Windows 3.1,世界上最快的处理器只有 66 兆赫兹,他自己都调侃说今天连球鞋里都不会塞这种芯片, 在当时的投资人和长辈眼里,电脑就是用来办公的,花重金把工作站级别的 3D 图形技术做便宜拿来打游戏,简直是不务正业。 但老黄这帮人偏偏是伴着电子游戏长大的第一代,游戏的乐趣和爆发力对他们来说是不用论证的常识,别人看不见,仅仅是因为上一代人没有这副眼镜。 说实话,放到今天做 AI、做产品、做内容也是一模一样的道理,现在大家手里的模型和工具越来越趋同, 真正抄不走的护城河,从来不是又多写了几行提示词,而是你过去的人生经历里,那些你觉得这不是明摆着吗、周围人却觉得奇怪或不重要的独特视角。 远见从来不是站在山顶俯瞰全世界的神通,而是你敢不敢认真对待自己这副不一样的眼镜,并且愿意在别人劝你找份正经工作的时候,咬着牙把路走通。
Body · AI translation
Those who bash Musk every day should come and see the true value of old Ma. Chamath Palihapitiya, a well-known Silicon Valley investor and regular on the All-In podcast, fired off directly in a recent interview: in the past decade, Silicon Valley has produced almost no truly impressive hardcore technological breakthroughs.
Except for Musk, who single-handedly pulled off reusable rockets, a global satellite communications network, and electric vehicles, the vast majority of Silicon Valley's top talent have mainly contributed AirPods and Instagram short videos.
To put it bluntly, the most impressive things of the past decade have been stuffing earbuds into ears and stuffing algorithmically edgy content into eyes.
People used to think Silicon Valley was a heavy-industry base building "rockets and power grids."
Now looking back, it seems more like an advanced consumer goods factory plus an attention harvester.
Apart from old Ma still battling gravity and manufacturing, many others are optimizing "how to get you to scroll two more minutes."
I think Chamath isn't simply bashing Silicon Valley, but pointing to a deeper question: where exactly are the tech industry's resources being allocated.
1️⃣ Hard tech vs. consumer internet: reusable rockets, satellite internet, and electric vehicles are breakthroughs in the "physical world," involving manufacturing, energy, and physical limits. AirPods and Reels are more software-plus-hardware consumer products, with fast growth and high profits, but they expand the boundaries of human capability only to a limited extent.
2️⃣ The flow of talent and capital: Silicon Valley's top engineering and product minds have poured in large numbers over the past decade into ad optimization, recommendation algorithms, and user time spent. These have indeed created enormous wealth and jobs, but what Chamath asks is: have there been breakthroughs at the level of "changing what humans can do"?
3️⃣ Musk as a contrast: he simultaneously pursues multiple hardcore paths (SpaceX, Tesla, Neuralink, etc.), turning "zero-to-one" physical systems into scalable products.
This deserves our rethinking: shouldn't top talent be more inclined to tackle the difficult, heavy, and slow problems?
SpaceX's reusable rockets drastically lowered launch costs, which is what made a megaconstellation like Starlink economically viable.
Tesla turned electric vehicles from an "eco-friendly niche" into a global mainstream, and also spawned the battery and autonomous driving industrial chains.
By contrast, many consumer internet companies have indeed pushed user experience to the extreme, but the answer to the question "looking back ten years later, what has been added to humanity's capability list" is indeed thin.
Of course, Silicon Valley hasn't been entirely unproductive: AI large models, chips, biotech, and cloud computing infrastructure are also major advances of the past decade; Chamath's remarks simply focus on hard breakthroughs in the physical world. https://t.co/GKoMwriXR1