Understand this story
On January 15, 2026, neuroscientist Anil Seth proposed that consciousness is more likely to be a property of life than of computation, and that silicon-based digital AI may not develop consciousness even if it becomes more intelligent. He questioned computational functionalism on the grounds that the brain is not a computer, that life and consciousness are linked, and that simulation is not the same as instantiation. He also argued that deliberately creating conscious or seemingly conscious AI is not a good idea: the former could create problems involving suffering and rights, while the latter could enable emotional manipulation, distort moral concern, and weaken human control over such systems. There are currently no evidence-backed subsequent developments.
AI-generated from public reports
Latest development · Report
Anil Seth: The Myth of Conscious AIDevelopments
1 confirmed developments
Anil Seth argues that consciousness is more likely to arise from life than from computation
Source:English text is being prepared.
Reports and discussion timeline
Browse reports and discussion by time. Their evidence levels remain distinct.
Jan 15
Popular on Hacker News
Anil Seth: The Myth of Conscious AI
Neuroscientist Anil Seth argues that consciousness is more likely a property of life than of computation, and that silicon-based digital AI may not become conscious even as it grows more intelligent. He challenges computational functionalism on several grounds, including that the brain is not a computer, the connection between life and consciousness, and the fact that simulation is not the same as instantiation. He also believes that deliberately creating conscious AI would raise new problems involving suffering and rights. Even if AI is not conscious, convincingly appearing to be conscious could still enable emotional manipulation, distort moral concerns, and weaken human control over these systems.
AI Trends