AI Trends

Virtual human Fang Taozi's first order, a false advertisement, was fined 68,200 yuan: AI endorsement of colored contact lenses "lies with eyes wide open"

36Kr · AIUpdated Nov 17 18:19

AI summary

Virtual human Fang Taozi was deemed to have made a false advertisement by the Guangzhou Panyu District Market Supervision Administration for claiming in a colored contact lens ad that "they were comfortable all day long," and was fined 68,200 yuan. Its operator "My Film and Television" had not obtained the Medical Advertisement Review Certificate, and the virtual human cannot actually use the product, constituting a fabricated use effect. Fang Taozi gained 400,000 followers within 30 days of debut, with a quoted price of 168,000 yuan for a 1-to-20-second video; its very first order flopped because the "never collapses" label contradicted its actual capabilities.

Body · AI translation

A virtual person with no eyeballs, no corneas, whose very act of "blinking" is nothing more than code simulation, says to the camera, "I've worn my colored contact lenses all day, and they're very comfortable." The irony here is extreme: when Fang Taozi debuted, its loudest label was "never collapses," yet its very first commercial deal collapsed over an ability it simply does not have.

A virtual person with no eyeballs, no corneas, whose very act of "blinking" is nothing more than code simulation, says to the camera, "I've worn my colored contact lenses all day, and they're very comfortable."

The penalty decision issued by the Guangzhou Panyu District Market Supervision Bureau characterized this line as false advertising and imposed a fine of 68,200 yuan. The amount is not large, but the irony of this matter is extreme: when Fang Taozi debuted, its loudest label was "never collapses," yet its very first commercial deal collapsed over an ability it simply does not have.

1. Why was Fang Taozi fined?

Fang Taozi's rate card caused quite a stir in the industry: 168,000 yuan for a 1-to-20-second video, 258,000 yuan for videos over 60 seconds—higher than a large number of real-person influencers with a million or even ten million followers. How could a virtual character that had been on the market for only 30 days, with 400,000 followers, be more expensive than a real person?

At the time, everyone was optimistic about Fang Taozi's "never collapses." Because it has no private life, no emotional breakdowns, won't go on a drunken rampage at three in the morning, and won't evade taxes. Brands had had enough of the uncontrollable risks of real-person endorsers, and virtual people looked like the ultimate solution. But Fang Taozi's first deal going wrong revealed an overlooked paradox: what brands really want from an endorser is not just "safety," but also "credibility."

Real-person influencers charge high rates because she really wore those colored contact lenses, really blinked in front of the camera all day, and fans believe her feelings are backed by a physical body. Once AI virtual people remove the variable of the "physical body," "safety" is achieved, but "credibility" disappears along with it. When a brand has a character with no sensations say "they're very comfortable to wear," the signal consumers receive is not "this product is good," but "this brand thinks I'm stupid."

Some netizens questioned: if AI can only say "these are colored contact lenses, diameter 14.2mm, base curve 8.6," then why doesn't the brand just put up the product detail page? Spending 250,000 yuan on a video buys a personalized tone of recommendation, the closeness of "I tried it for you." And it is precisely this part that the law does not allow AI to provide.

Colored contact lenses are not ordinary accessories. They are Class III medical devices, the highest risk category, and a Medical Advertisement Review Certificate must be obtained before advertising. Fang Taozi's operator, "My Film and Television," did not have this certificate—that is a procedural violation. The more fundamental problem lies at the substantive level: the Advertising Law requires that endorsers must not recommend or testify for products they have not used, and a virtual person can never "use" anything.

AI images can be used for brand display, product introduction, and spoken selling points, but saying "I personally tested it and it works well" or "it feels very comfortable when I use it" is false advertising. Fang Taozi's line "because these colored contact lenses have high-gloss axis stabilization, you can blink with confidence"—the issue is not whether this technical description is accurate, but that the subject saying it has no physiological act of "blinking" to refer to at all.

The regulatory authorities' chain of reasoning is well-founded: virtual people have no real wearing experience, and virtual people cannot claim subjective feelings; therefore this constitutes fabricating usage effects and is determined to be false advertising.

2. Does the operator's claim of "insufficient professionalism" hold up?

The person in charge of "My Film and Television" admitted in an interview that the team had been negligent in business operations and lacked professionalism, and that after discovering the problem they had taken the ad down and rejected all commercial cooperation, refocusing on content creation. The attitude can be considered sincere, but "insufficient professionalism" clearly underestimates the nature of the problem.

As a team that started out making AI short dramas, its core capabilities are content production and character operation. The reason Fang Taozi could gain 400,000 followers in 30 days is the personality-rich, story-driven heroine in "The Girl Who Was Laid Off." But the commercial deals brands brought over wanted "this character to tell people my product is good." This is no longer just a matter of different trades being far apart; it is separated by advertising regulations and the product liability system.

It is worth noting that since July this year, this company has registered copyrights for 192 works of fine art, most of them named after characters. It is mass-producing virtual character assets, and Fang Taozi is merely the first one to break out. If subsequent characters copy the same monetization path, every commercial deal will face the same question. Does this category allow AI to speak? For medical treatments, medicines, medical devices, and health foods, the law's requirements for endorsers are equally strict for AI.

So "can AI actually do advertising"? An analysis by Cover News gives the answer: AI can objectively display, but cannot fabricate experiences. Cultural tourism digital humans can explain history, virtual shopping guides can quote parameters and sizes, and government affairs announcers can read notices. These are all "display" and "communication," but they cannot vouch for products.

The core selling points of colored contact lens ads have never been just parameters; the selling points are bodily sensations like "do they look good on me," "are they comfortable," and "will they dry out." Clothing can let AI "display" how it looks worn, and snacks can let AI "describe" the taste. Although there are also borderline risks, at least the products themselves do not require the endorser to possess physiological organs.

This article comes from the WeChat public account "Financial Gossip Girl Channel" (ID: baguanvpindao), author: Mu Bai, published by 36Kr with authorization.

Source

36Kr · AI