England's university regulator warns about AI cheating, calls for more pen-and-paper exams and oral defenses
The Office for Students (OfS), England's higher education regulator, has warned that universities are too vulnerable in preventing AI cheating, requiring the adoption of assessment methods less susceptible to AI misuse, such as paper-based exams, oral presentations and oral defenses, and threatening universities that fail to effectively stop students from misusing AI with fines and other disciplinary measures. The OfS report says student surveys show that more than 90% of students use AI to help complete their assignments, practices vary widely between institutions, and too many schools still rely on unsupervised coursework. The OfS has issued new guidance urging universities to make greater use of secure assessments such as in-person exams, presentations and oral defenses, and praised the University of Bath's dual-track approach.
Why read this
AI score 57
England's regulator issues fine threats and a list of assessment methods over AI cheating, exposing institutional divisions among universities on AI use.
Topics
Body · AI translation
England's university regulator warns of AI cheating and calls for more pen-and-paper exams Phoenix Tech Download the app for exclusive early access November 11, 2026, 11:22:55 From Beijing Updated November 11, 2026, 11:46:18
Phoenix Tech News, November 11 (Beijing time) — According to a report by the UK's Financial Times, England's higher education regulator, the Office for Students (OfS), has warned that universities are too vulnerable in preventing AI cheating and need to adopt assessment methods less susceptible to AI misuse, such as paper exams, oral presentations and oral defenses.
In a report released on Wednesday, the OfS said AI poses a "generational risk" to the integrity and reputation of universities, and the regulator threatened fines and other disciplinary action if institutions fail to effectively stop students from misusing AI. The body also acknowledged that AI presents a "huge opportunity" to improve teaching, but said universities need to do more to prevent cheating from becoming normalized and eroding students' ability to learn.
Student surveys show that more than 90% of students use AI to help complete their assignments, prompting some universities to redesign their assessments, including reviving the medieval-era oral defense (viva voce). The OfS report said practices vary "widely" among institutions and acknowledged criticism that the regulator has been slow to set clear rules in the four years since ChatGPT emerged.
The report praised some universities for redesigning their assessments, but noted that too many still rely on unsupervised coursework, which is highly susceptible to AI misuse. Students frequently report that some peers "use AI to complete assessments, sometimes in just a few minutes, yet receive grades similar to those who completed the work themselves." Many students "see AI as the most efficient route to high marks" and "feel disadvantaged" if they do not use this powerful technology.
Josh Fleming, the OfS's director of strategy, said AI "poses a generational risk to the system" and undermines universities' ability to assess students fairly. "We need to see greater efforts to address these risks, including more use of assessments that do not rely on AI," he said.
The OfS has issued new guidance urging universities to make greater use of "secure assessments," such as in-person exams, presentations and oral defenses. Under a fully overhauled quality regime, universities must demonstrate that "assessment design is resilient to AI." The report also stressed that, if used properly, AI can help provide rapid personalized feedback and enable lecturers to develop better teaching materials.
Fleming urged universities to "act proactively rather than waiting for the regulator to come knocking and find the problems." He praised the "dual-track" approach at the University of Bath: on the one hand, setting exams in which students cannot use AI; on the other, setting other assessments that explicitly assume students will use AI.
Universities UK said many institutions "have already made significant changes to the way they assess students," including more in-person exams, presentations, oral defenses, process-based assessments, and assessments that integrate AI in controlled ways. "Different disciplines require different approaches, and universities should have the flexibility to adopt the assessment methods that best support learning outcomes," the association added.
For more first-hand news, please download the Phoenix News app and subscribe to Phoenix Tech. For in-depth reporting, search "Phoenix Tech" on WeChat.