AI News

How does The New York Times exploit Jensen Huang and his leather jacket?

HuxiuUpdated Nov 16 21:09

AI summary

From November 8 to 13, four RSS channels of The New York Times published 36 reports related to Jensen Huang, and two opinion-page columns mocked his character with his leather jacket and a $1,000 tip. The article points out that the Sulzberger family controls 9 of the 13 directors through 0.48% of Class B shares, that about 71% of revenue comes from 13.76 million subscribers, and states that The New York Times has AI conflicts of interest with OpenAI and Nvidia.

Body · AI translation

[[**After the Huang Renxun scandal, The New York Times and other British and American media concentrated within days on a moral narrative to besiege him. Behind this are intertwined racial bias, subscription politics, AI conflicts of interest, and the computing-power game among media owners. He has become the scapegoat for AI bubble anxiety.**

**Key Points**

**1. The moral siege is underpinned by racial double standards**

From November 8 to 13, four RSS channels of The New York Times published 36 reports on Huang Renxun. Two columns used his leather jacket and a $1,000 tip to mock his character; similar scandals involving white CEOs mostly stop at corporate governance.

The Sulzberger family controls 9 of 13 directors with 0.48% of Class B shares; about 71% of revenue comes from 13.76 million subscribers, 91% of whom lean Democratic. Cursing Huang Renxun has become a surefire business for stabilizing subscription fees.

**3. AI conflicts of interest and foundation funding influence coverage**

The New York Times sued OpenAI and others and receives AI licensing fees from Amazon; Nvidia is an investor in OpenAI and a chip rival to Amazon; Tarbell received more than $4.7 million in funding, and the EA camp installed more than 80 AI journalists.

**4. Huang Renxun becomes the scapegoat for AI bubble anxiety**

This article is from the WeChat public account: Dongcha Beating, author: Sleepy, cover image from: Visual China

From November 8 to 13, The New York Times, a newspaper that bills itself as the conscience of American journalism, published 36 reports and commentaries related to Huang Renxun in just four major RSS channels.

Its opinion section ran two columns in less than 24 hours. One made lewd jokes about his black leather jacket and his body; the other, written by his biographer, turned his early experience as a dishwasher and the $1,000 tip he left for a Denny's waitress into a narcissist's performance of pleasing himself.

Immediately afterward, at least eight major British and American media outlets rushed in.

《I Wrote Jensen Huang's Biography.Here's What Led to His Downfall.》

Many people's first reaction is that this is about race. That layer does exist. The old American media routine for writing about Asian Americans appeared again this time, without missing a single beat. But it is only the most superficial layer.

In this public opinion arena that claims to be a free press, no article becomes a hit for no reason, and no moral siege is launched purely out of a sense of justice.

Dongcha Beating dug up reports from the past few weeks and the history of the newspaper's owning family, then compared them with the resumes of the editorial staff, the money flowing into journalism, and the respective businesses of the media owners, and found that behind those two columns there is something deeper.

Beneath race, there are at least four more layers.

The newspaper itself. A family that holds control through 0.48% of the shares, and 13.76 million subscribers whose political positions are highly concentrated.

Readers can hardly see these relationships on the pages. Nor does anyone need to coordinate among them. Each party is simply doing what benefits itself, and in November 2026, they all aimed at the same person.

Therefore, the Huang Renxun on the pages of mainstream American media is a narrative product jointly processed by these forces.

What we want to criticize is precisely the malice, double standards, and desire to manipulate the narrative displayed by mainstream American elite media represented by The New York Times in this matter.

Two Articles

On the night of November 11, the opinion section of The New York Times published its first column. At that time, three days had passed since Huang Renxun sent an apology letter to all employees, and the Nvidia board was still discussing whether he should stay or go. The author was Anand Giridharadas, and the title was "Huang Renxun Betrayed the Leather Jacket Community."

The entire article uses a sarcastic, trolling tone. He pretends to be a representative of middle-aged leather jacket enthusiasts and complains that Huang Renxun's scandal has ruined the reputation of leather jackets. In the subtitle, he writes that one person's physical failure should not tarnish our "second skin." In the main text, he writes a rather vulgar line, to the effect that we should not throw out the innocent lambskin just because of the "lustful flesh" beneath the leather jacket.

This is the response of the opinion section of America's largest newspaper in the face of the biggest corporate governance crisis of the year.

But just three years ago, the same piece of clothing was another symbol in The New York Times. On June 14, 2023, the paper's chief fashion critic, Vanessa Friedman, wrote a feature titled "Is This a Trillion-Dollar Look?", treating Huang Renxun's black leather jacket as a symbol of the AI era. On July 17 this year, a signed Tom Ford leather jacket that Huang Renxun had worn in Taipei was auctioned at Sotheby's, with an estimate of $40,000 to $60,000. Forty-five collectors made 65 bids, and it finally sold for $960,000, with all proceeds donated to charity.

On the day Huang Renxun announced his resignation, November 12, the opinion section published a second column.

The author was Huang Renxun's biographer, Stephen Witt, and the title was "I Wrote Huang Renxun's Biography. Here's What Led to His Downfall."

To write the biography "The Thinking Machine," published in April 2025, Witt was granted close access to observe Huang Renxun and Nvidia. He interviewed Huang Renxun himself six times, as well as his friends, investors, and employees. The book won the Financial Times and Schroders Business Book of the Year Award, was translated into 23 languages, and brought him both fame and fortune.

On the day of Jensen Huang's downfall, this biographer appeared simultaneously on the New York Times op-ed page and the paper's flagship podcast Hard Fork, framing the whole affair as "an old story about male arrogance," and quoting an anonymous former employee as saying that an office romance gave Jensen Huang "a narcissist's thrill."

He admitted that he had heard rumors of Jensen Huang's philandering earlier this year but had been unable to confirm them. Yet when comparing Jensen Huang to Trump, he still wrote that both men possessed "rage, narcissism, and lust." Three days later, an interview he had recorded in April of this year was dug up, in which he said Jensen Huang "has a kind of cult-leader quality about him."

The most vicious part of the entire article was the passage about tips.

Witt wrote that Jensen Huang "worked as a dishwasher, and he never lets you forget it." He liked going to corner diners and liked leaving exaggeratedly large tips. Once, the two had breakfast at a Denny's, and Jensen Huang left the waitress $1,000. Witt himself admitted that Jensen Huang had not made any show of it when giving the money—it was only afterward that Witt went to ask the waitress and found out.

Immediately after, Witt wrote a line that struck at the heart. He said, "I began to suspect this was a performance," one put on for Jensen Huang himself, to please himself.

An immigrant boy who was sent at age 9 to a reform school for troubled youths in Kentucky, where he scrubbed toilets every day, and who at 15 washed dishes and waited tables at a Denny's—after achieving fame and success, he returned to the inexpensive fast-food restaurant where he had once worked, quietly left a waitress a $1,000 tip without making a show of it, and on the pages of the New York Times, generosity had no possible innocent interpretation.

The American writer Janet Malcolm wrote in the opening of her 1990 book The Journalist and the Murderer something to the effect that every journalist who is not too stupid or too full of himself to notice what is going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible—ingratiating himself with his subject like a confidence trickster, only to stab him in the back at the moment he is most unguarded.

In fact, more than a month earlier, Witt had already written about Jensen Huang once in the New York Times.

On October 7, a month before the scandal erupted, Witt published a long article in the New York Times criticizing Jensen Huang for ignoring AI risks and for being too close to Trump, but the article also said, "Mr. Huang is the most capable person I have ever met."

What kind of people wrote these two articles, and what kind of people decided to put them on the page?

First, look at the leather-jacket guy Anand Giridharadas.

On the pages of the New York Times, this 45-year-old writer is a spearhead of criticism against the billionaire class. In 2018 he published the bestseller Winners Take All, criticizing Silicon Valley and Wall Street billionaires for using philanthropy to mask plunder, and afterward he became the most sought-after moral star of the American liberal intelligentsia.

But his own background is precisely the class he criticizes: he grew up in a wealthy neighborhood of Cleveland, and his father was a director at McKinsey—that is, a senior partner. He studied successively at the University of Michigan, Oxford University, and Harvard University, and his first job after graduating from college was in McKinsey's Mumbai office. In 2011, he received the Aspen Institute's Henry Crown Fellowship and entered a top-tier elite circle funded by super-billionaires.

Within the framework of Winners Take All, the generosity of the rich is inherently suspect; every charitable donation is whitewashing privilege.

Next, look at Stephen Witt, who turned the tip into a hypocritical performance.

Witt is 47 this year and graduated from the University of Chicago's mathematics department in 2001. Before becoming a nonfiction writer, he worked for six years at hedge funds in Chicago and New York. In 2008 he left the financial industry to do economic development work in Africa, entered Columbia University's journalism school around 2010, and afterward changed careers to write books.

Over the past year, he has been one of the authors on the New York Times op-ed page who continually discuss AI risks. In the final interview for the Jensen Huang biography, Witt pressed Jensen Huang on the dangers of AI, which angered Jensen Huang, who had never agreed with AI doomerism.

We have no way of knowing Witt's true motives when he wrote the November 12 article, but readers should at least know that this biographer and Jensen Huang had already clashed head-on over issues related to AI safety.

And the person who put both articles on the page at the same time was Kathleen Kingsbury, editor of the New York Times opinion section.

Kingsbury took over the opinion section in the summer of 2020. At the time, former editor James Bennet had resigned after publishing a column by Senator Tom Cotton advocating sending in troops to quell protests, which sparked controversy inside the paper. After Kingsbury took office, she cut the opinion section's overall output by about 25 to 30 percent. In an interview with the Columbia Journalism Review in August of this year, she said the opinion section would require authors to go back and contact the people they criticized, giving them a chance to respond.

But on November 11 and 12, whether it was Giridharadas's vulgar mockery or Witt's "narcissist's thrill," no response from Jensen Huang's side could be seen on the page.

Kingsbury's résumé is likewise delicate. She graduated from Georgetown University's School of Foreign Service as an undergraduate, studied Chinese at Georgetown and Fudan University, and later went to Shanghai on a Pulitzer Traveling Fellowship from Columbia University's journalism school, working as a Time magazine correspondent in Hong Kong and a BusinessWeek correspondent in Shanghai. An editor who has reported in Hong Kong and Shanghai and studied Chinese should not be unfamiliar with the dignity and taboos of Chinese society.

The one who signed off on publishing these two articles was none other than her.

Crossing the Line

But even if these three elites themselves carried arrogance and personal grudges, why did they dare to write about the founder of the world's most valuable company in a tone that bordered on insulting his very personhood?

If the person who had made the same mistake were not Jensen Huang, a Chinese immigrant from Taiwan, but a native-born white American CEO, how would The New York Times have written about it?

There is no shortage of precedents. In 2018, Intel's white CEO Brian Krzanich was forced to resign over a relationship with an employee; in 2019, McDonald's white CEO Steve Easterbrook was fired by the board for having a relationship with an employee; in 2023, BP's white CEO Bernard Looney lost his job for failing to honestly disclose a relationship with a colleague.

We pulled up The New York Times' coverage of those three scandals at the time and found that most of it stayed within the bounds of corporate governance, board independence, and compliance investigations. We did not find any column mocking Krzanich's clothing, nor any biographer digging into whether Easterbrook's tips to waiters in his early years were a narcissist putting on a show, and no one wrote jokes about their "lustful flesh."

In 2021, when Bill Gates' extramarital affair with an employee during his time at Microsoft, as well as his pursuit of female employees in the workplace, were exposed, The New York Times published a long investigative report, and its opinion section also ran columns criticizing him, but we did not find any article writing that his signature sweater had betrayed the sweater community.

The most naked double standard occurred with Bezos.

In early 2019, the extramarital affair and private text messages of Amazon founder Bezos were exposed by the tabloid National Enquirer, and Bezos subsequently published a long post accusing the tabloid of extorting him. A few days later, one of The New York Times' most weighty columnists, Pulitzer Prize winner Maureen Dowd, wrote a dedicated column that included the line that set the tone: "But at least for now, he is a hero."

Also a tech giant worth hundreds of billions of dollars, also betraying his marriage, yet Bezos became a hero fighting the tabloids on The New York Times opinion pages, and afterward no one demanded that he leave Amazon because of it; Oracle founder Larry Ellison had scandals throughout his life, and no one ever touched his position.

Only in the case of Asian founder Jensen Huang did he not only lose within four days the company he had built by hand over 33 years, but The New York Times also stripped off his leather jacket, denied his origins as a dishwasher, and put him on a cultural guillotine for a public shaming parade.

Why?

Because in the subconscious of the American mainstream elite, Jensen Huang's unforgivable offense lies in the fact that he broke the caste boundary that white American society has drawn for Asian Americans.

In 1999, political scientist Claire Jean Kim proposed a "racial triangulation" model. On the dimension of diligence and intelligence, the American mainstream narrative desperately elevates Asian Americans, but on the dimension of cultural belonging and the legitimacy of power, Asian Americans are pinned to the position of "perpetual foreigner" and are not allowed to enter the true core of rule.

Diagram of Claire Jean Kim's "racial triangulation" model | Image source: Drenched

In 2001, scholar David Eng said in Racial Castration that the premise for mainstream American culture to accept Asian men is to first "emasculate" them. A safe Asian man is best a dull engineer with his head down writing code in a cubicle.

Jensen Huang simply refused to stay in that cage.

In Silicon Valley, where Asian Americans have long been pressed down by the "bamboo ceiling," he turned a graphics card company that was once on the verge of bankruptcy into the world's most valuable company. He wears Tom Ford and motorcycle leather jackets, gives speeches like a rock star in arenas filled with tens of thousands of people, and chats and laughs with presidents and heads of state. Marlon Brando and James Dean wore black leather jackets, and that was the rebellious privilege of white men; for a yellow-skinned immigrant to wear a black leather jacket and command the global tech world is, in the eyes of some American cultural elites, usurpation.

And Witt's portrayal of the $1,000 tip Jensen Huang quietly left as a pathological psychology of self-gratification also uses an old craft inherited by the American press for 150 years: the inscrutable Asian, the unfathomable Asian.

From the 1873 San Francisco Chronicle headline "The Chinese Invasion, 900,000 Are Coming," to the 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act, to the screen image of Fu Manchu, the core of this rhetoric is that Asian politeness is a mask, humility is a disguise, and generosity must conceal calculation. As Walter Lippmann said, "Most of the time we do not first see and then define; we first define and then see."

The label of "perpetual foreigner," when placed on Jensen Huang, also has a more specific target.

A team led by Princeton University sociologist Xie Yu analyzed all 267,000 China-related reports in The New York Times from 1970 to 2019 and found that how this newspaper wrote about China in a given year could explain 54% of the change in American public opinion toward China the following year; for reports involving the government and ideology, every year over five decades had more negative than positive coverage.

However, if this siege is explained only by skin color and ethnicity, many things still do not add up.

The loudest voices defending Jensen Huang were, precisely, a group of white men. Musk said bringing Jensen Huang on board "would be an honor," Sequoia's Shaun Maguire said he is "irreplaceable" to America's AI leadership, Bill Ackman said "even the most remarkable people make mistakes," and Epic Games founder Tim Sweeney said the board pushing him out was as foolish as Apple pushing out Steve Jobs back in the day.

Musk replied that bringing Jensen Huang on board "would be an honor" | Image source: X

Race gave them a sharp weapon, but it was not the trigger that fired the shot.

Why did The New York Times choose precisely this moment to cast Jensen Huang as an irredeemable villain? To answer that question, one has to look at the business conducted behind closed doors in that building.

Two-Faced

The New York Times dares to strike the pose of America's highest moral tribunal, relying on the slogan printed in the upper left corner of its front page for more than a century, "All the News That's Fit to Print," and on the pledge its founder Adolph Ochs made in 1896: "without fear or favor."

The New York Times front page of May 16, 1918 | Image source: The New York Times

Who decides what news is "fit to print," and who counts as morally corrupt?

The answer is the Ochs and Sulzberger families.

As of March 2026, The New York Times Company had 161 million Class A shares circulating on the secondary market, plus another 780,000 Class B shares that do not trade publicly. Those 780,000 Class B shares account for only 0.48% of total equity, yet they can elect 9 of the board's 13 directors. Some 94.6% of all Class B shares are locked in family trusts, and the trust charters require trustees to veto any sale or merger that could cause the family to lose control.

Earlier this year, Buffett's Berkshire bought about $350 million worth of New York Times stock, yet faced with that 0.48% hereditary privileged share class, even the Oracle of Omaha could not get his hands on a single board seat.

Since this family's newspaper displays such a strong moral fastidiousness about Jensen Huang's extramarital affair and office romance, we might as well leaf through this family's own story.

According to the family history "The Trust," published in 1999, Arthur Hays Sulzberger, the publisher who ran The New York Times from 1935 to 1961 and the great-grandfather of current publisher A.G. Sulzberger, had a years-long extramarital affair with the British actress Madeleine Carroll.

As for the current publisher's father, fourth-generation publisher Arthur Sulzberger Jr., in 2008 he separated and divorced his first wife after 33 years of marriage, remarried in 2014, and a few years later headed toward divorce again. In August 2021, the New York Post's Page Six gossip section reported that the divorce was "getting ugly," with his ex-wife's side accusing him of failing to honor the prenuptial agreement.

According to a February 2023 profile in New York magazine, just as Page Six was reporting on the matter, Sulzberger Jr. brought in Risa Heller, one of Manhattan's most famous crisis PR specialists.

Heller's clients have included politician Anthony Weiner, caught in an indecent-photo scandal in 2011; Harvey Weinstein in 2015; and CNN president Jeff Zucker, who resigned in 2022 after concealing a relationship with a colleague. In October 2022, in her apartment overlooking the East River, which had a resale value of nearly $5 million, she hosted a book party for Maggie Haberman, The New York Times' most prominent political reporter, and a group of New York Times editors and reporters all turned up.

On one side is the newspaper family's own extramarital affairs and divorce disputes, shielded by a family trust and managed by crisis PR; on the other, a Taiwanese immigrant engineer with no family trust to protect him makes a mistake, and this family's newspaper transforms into a moral crusader, hanging his leather jacket up on the page for public display.

Executive editor Joe Kahn, who holds day-to-day control over the paper's newsroom, likewise comes from this elite circle. His father, Leo Kahn, was a co-founder of the office-supply chain giant Staples.

He himself went from the elite boarding school Middlesex School to Harvard, earned a master's in East Asian studies, and starting in 1989 was posted to China for the Dallas Morning News and then The Wall Street Journal; from 2003 to 2007 he served as Beijing bureau chief for The New York Times. The person who runs The New York Times newsroom today began his career precisely by scrutinizing China.

But a more direct driver than family privilege and the editor's résumé is that the way this newspaper makes money has changed.

The New York Times of the past survived on department-store and automobile advertising, and its benefactors liked steady, inoffensive reporting that alienated no one; today's New York Times survives on subscribers whose political stance is highly purified.

In the third quarter of 2026, The New York Times reported quarterly revenue of $768.5 million, of which about 71% came from 13.76 million subscribers, while advertising accounted for only 19%. A Pew Research Center survey found that among readers who rely on The New York Times as their main source of political news, 91% are Democrats or lean Democratic; after leaving his post as former editorial page editor, James Bennet revealed that more than 95% of the paper's subscribers identify as Democrats or independent voters, and that the marketing department even treated the "liberal image" in readers' eyes as a selling point in an internal memo. A 2010 study by economists Gentzkow and Shapiro also found that the primary factor determining an American newspaper's political leanings is reader preference.

Simply by tracing, in line with subscriber tastes, how The New York Times has written about Jensen Huang over the past three years, one can see a noose tightening step by step.

In 2023, he was a novel "trillion-dollar look" in the style section; on December 5, 2024, the investigative report "How One of the World's Richest Men Avoided $8 Billion in Taxes" placed him in the "rich and heartless" column; in July 2025, the focus shifted to his lobbying of Trump to ease chip exports; in September 2026, the paper's star columnist Ezra Klein went to Nvidia headquarters and recorded a highly charged face-to-face interview; and by November, Witt pointed out in his column that Huang's growing closeness to Trump was "no coincidence."

In the eyes of these 13.76 million liberal subscribers, an Asian hardware tycoon worth hundreds of billions, who does not believe in AI doomsday scenarios, and who is growing closer to Trump, was already a perfect villain. Scolding him is a business that reliably earns subscription fees.

The newspaper also has a layer of its own vested interests.

In December 2023, The New York Times sued OpenAI and Microsoft in federal court, accusing them of using millions of articles to train large models without permission; in December 2025, it sued the AI search company Perplexity. Neither case has been decided, and in the third quarter of this year alone, the paper recorded $3.8 million in "generative AI litigation expenses." In this litigation, Jensen Huang stands behind the defendants: Nvidia is OpenAI's most important computing power supplier, announced in September 2025 that it would invest up to $100 billion in OpenAI, and is also an investor in Perplexity.

On the other side, The New York Times signed an AI licensing agreement with Amazon in May 2025, allowing Amazon to use its news, recipes, and sports content to train its own models, with licensing fees reportedly around $20 million to $30 million a year. Amazon's self-developed Trainium chips, meanwhile, are competing with Nvidia for business.

Suing Nvidia's customers, taking money from Nvidia's competitors, and then putting Nvidia's founder on trial in its pages—these two layers of conflict of interest fall outside the scope of any existing disclosure rules, and across 36 reports about Jensen Huang, The New York Times indeed did not mention a single word of it.

The person who should have been watching for these shenanigans on readers' behalf was laid off nine years earlier. On May 31, 2017, The New York Times eliminated the "public editor" position, which had existed for 14 years and was the only independent watchdog inside the newspaper specifically tasked with finding fault with the paper on readers' behalf.

Underwater revenue

But The New York Times was not the only one besieging Jensen Huang this time. What about those British and American media outlets that rushed in after it and, within 48 hours, filled the internet with leather-jacket jokes?

The Washington Post signed with OpenAI in April 2025; Business Insider's parent company signed a contract with OpenAI worth tens of millions of euros a year as early as 2023, and later expanded its cooperation with Microsoft; The Guardian reached a partnership with OpenAI in February 2025; The Independent joined Perplexity's revenue-sharing program; Forbes simultaneously receives licensing fees from Amazon Alexa+ and Google; even The Cut, the fashion media outlet that joined the mockery, is part of New York magazine, whose former owner Vox Media also signed an agreement with OpenAI in 2024.

Coefficient Giving, funded by Facebook co-founder Dustin Moskovitz and formerly known as Open Philanthropy, is one of the most important funders in the effective altruism camp. The foundation has allocated more than $4.7 million to the Tarbell AI Journalism Center, which specifically funds AI reporting.

The New York Post disclosed that the entire EA camp has funded and placed more than 80 full-time journalists in major mainstream newsrooms across Europe and the United States.

The Tarbell Center announced AI newsroom funding on October 5 | Image source: Tarbell Center

This money also flowed to louder, top-tier opinion leaders. Hard Fork, The New York Times' technology podcast—the flagship podcast that invited biographer Witt on the show to sharply criticize Huang on the day he resigned—saw its two former hosts, Kevin Roose and Casey Newton, launch their own venture and, in cooperation with NPR, launch a new program, Machine Gods. Tarbell directly allocated $480,000 to that program and conveniently allocated another $250,000 to NPR's "Power and Influence" reporting team.

As for Ezra Klein, The New York Times' top columnist who went to Nvidia headquarters in September this year to confront Jensen Huang face to face, he publicly said as early as 2021, when he appeared on the EA flagship podcast 80,000 Hours, that he supported foundation funding of journalism: "I like the model of building institutions within institutions." Future Perfect, a vertical under Vox, which he co-founded, received $200,000 in funding from the SBF family foundation in 2022.

The AI company with the deepest ties to this circle is Anthropic. Its 2021 Series A was led by EA spiritual leader Jaan Tallinn, with Moskovitz also participating. Its CEO, Dario Amodei, and Jensen Huang had publicly argued for two years over chip exports and AI risk, and Huang said he "almost entirely disagreed" with what Amodei said. On November 19, one week after Huang's resignation, Anthropic will list on Nasdaq.

We must draw the boundary clearly: there is no public evidence directly proving that these foundations, Anthropic, or these journalists participated in pushing Huang out. Nvidia itself is still Anthropic's chip supplier and investor.

But money underwater never needs to directly buy a particular article. It only needs to stuff dozens of journalists carrying the same framework into major newsrooms, and it can determine what moral vocabulary the entire Western media circle will use to write his eulogy when Jensen Huang, who never took AI doomerism seriously, falls.

Two Machines

Having traced the authors who wield the pen, the families that own the newspapers, and the foundations underwater, we finally come to the core structure.

In this siege, why would sworn rivals like The Washington Post and The Wall Street Journal move in step with The New York Times? Why would Musk, Peter Thiel, and this group of Silicon Valley right-wingers, in turn, desperately cry injustice for Jensen Huang?

In 1928, Edward Bernays, the father of modern public relations, wrote at the opening of Propaganda that the conscious and intelligent manipulation of the habits and opinions of the masses is an important element of democratic society, and that those who manipulate this unseen mechanism constitute an "invisible government" that truly rules the country.

A hundred years later, there are at least two such "invisible governments" in the United States. They are hostile to each other, yet in November 2026 they aimed at the same person.

The first is the owners of traditional media.

Most of today's leading American media outlets are held in the hands of a few families. These families each have a place at the AI card table: some are Nvidia's rivals, some are its most indispensable customers, and some sell content to its biggest buyers.

To them, Nvidia—with a market capitalization swollen to its peak and gross margins above 70%—has long ceased to be an ordinary chip supplier. It is the computing-power creditor that the entire Silicon Valley and Wall Street most want to escape.

Bezos is both Nvidia's customer and its rival.

In 2013, he bought The Washington Post for $250 million. His Amazon is a major Nvidia customer, while its self-developed Trainium chips are competing for Nvidia's business. CEO Andy Jassy said in his April shareholder letter this year that if Amazon's chip business were taken separately, its revenue would exceed $50 billion. Amazon had already invested $8 billion in Anthropic and in April this year committed up to another $25 billion. Bezos himself also became co-CEO of the AI startup Project Prometheus last year, and the company received $6.2 billion as soon as it was founded.

Nor is he a boss who leaves the newsroom alone. Before the 2024 election, The Washington Post pulled an already-written editorial endorsing Harris. The publisher who announced it, William Lewis, was the very person who in 2020, at The Wall Street Journal, expressed only "regret" over the "Sick Man of Asia" headline.

Then look at the Murdoch family, selling content to Nvidia's biggest buyers.

Its Wall Street Journal was first to report on November 11 that "Nvidia is preparing to oust CEO Jensen Huang," and two days later its editorial headline was "Of Course Jensen Huang Has to Go." The New York Post, owned by the same family, ran the front-page headline "HUANG HUANG BANG BANG" on November 9, punning on Huang's surname, and was called out by the Asian American Journalists Association.

The New York Post's national front page on November 9 | Image source: X

Murdoch's News Corp signed a five-year content licensing deal with OpenAI worth more than $250 million, and in March this year signed another deal with Meta worth up to $50 million a year. Both are among Nvidia's biggest buyers, and both are developing their own chips to pay a little less "Nvidia tax."

What kind of Nvidia would the people paying Murdoch most like to see?

The Ellison family's position is exactly the opposite. Oracle doesn't have its own AI chips; it is one of Nvidia's most indispensable customers. In October this year, Paramount, controlled by the Ellison family, completed its acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery, bringing CBS News and CNN under the same family name. Larry Ellison's Oracle is one of Nvidia's largest customers; according to a 2025 Financial Times report, for the Stargate data center in Abilene, Texas alone, Oracle is set to buy about 400,000 GB200s.

After Jensen Huang's resignation, the headline in CBS News was "Jensen Huang's Departure Shakes Nvidia and Opens Opportunities for Rivals in the AI Boom." No leather jacket, no tip—it reads more like an industry briefing.

Once you understand this card table, you can understand the calculations of these media bosses.

The deeper Nvidia's moat and the more irreplaceable Jensen Huang's personal aura, the more passive the downstream major manufacturers and cloud giants become at the computing-power negotiating table. An Nvidia that has lost its creator god and returned to rule by professional managers is exactly what all the giants that buy and build chips have been longing for.

And on the opposite side of the traditional media machine, the Silicon Valley tech right, led by Musk, Peter Thiel, and Marc Andreessen, is starting up a second machine.

This group has long-standing grievances with the traditional elite media. In 2007, Gawker's Valleywag forcibly exposed Peter Thiel's homosexuality. Thiel endured it for years, then secretly provided about $10 million to fund wrestler Hulk Hogan's lawsuit against Gawker, and in 2016 drove the outlet straight into bankruptcy.

Right-wing thinker Curtis Yarvin lumped The New York Times and Ivy League universities together as "the Cathedral," mocking these liberal elites for monopolizing the right to interpret morality like the medieval church; in 2023, Andreessen, in his "Techno-Optimist Manifesto," simply put "tech ethics" and "trust and safety" directly on his list of enemies.

Excerpt from a16z's "Techno-Optimist Manifesto" | Image source: a16z

Faced with traditional media whose public trust, according to Gallup surveys, has already fallen below 28%, the Silicon Valley right's method is to bypass reporters and control the distribution machine themselves.

Musk is even more capricious. He simply bought Twitter. On the night of the 2023 Super Bowl, because the views on one of his tweets were lower than Biden's, the next day Twitter's engineering team rolled out a "superuser multiplier" that applied only to him, forcibly amplifying the weight of his tweets by 1,000 times.

When The New York Times went after Jensen Huang's leather jacket to please its liberal subscribers, Musk and the Silicon Valley right immediately realized the prey had delivered itself. A tech hero who created a trillion-dollar market value being besieged by The New York Times in such a despicable posture was simply a perfect case to prove that "the traditional media has completely rotted and been reduced to a liberal smear machine."

Sacrifice

In 1974, French television broadcast an interview with Hannah Arendt, in which she said, "If everybody always lies to you, the consequence is not that you believe the lies, but rather that nobody believes anything any longer," and a people that no longer believes in anything can no longer make judgments, "and with such a people you can then do what you please."

Back to the last question: why did all the undercurrents, hostility, and calculation converge precisely at this moment in November 2026 and choose Jensen Huang?

In March this year, Fortune magazine reporter Sharon Goldman wrote an article asking a question. Society's anger at AI is burning everywhere—some fear it will take their jobs, some fear it will devour electricity and create bubbles—so why is Jensen Huang never the one being cursed? Her explanation was that the people selling shovels in a gold rush are rarely scrutinized; back then, the ones at the center of public anger were the railroad tycoons, while the companies that supplied steel rails to the railroads were rarely remembered.

Eight months later, the shovel seller's umbrella shattered.

According to statistics from the UK's Financial Times, since June this year, the shovel-seller sector supplying data centers has shed $4.2 trillion in market value; on October 16, US tech stocks erased more than $1 trillion in a single day, international oil prices broke above $100, and the 10-year US Treasury yield broke through 5%.

Wall Street, Silicon Valley, and Washington are all shrouded in the same fear: hundreds of billions of dollars are poured into the computing-power black hole every year, and if it ultimately cannot be converted into commercial returns, who will take the blame for the most expensive bubble in human history?

On the day of the October 16 crash, Jensen Huang was still in Berlin telling reporters, "This too shall pass." Less than four weeks later, he himself was pushed onto the altar.

In his 1982 book The Scapegoat, French thinker René Girard summarized the pattern by which human societies resolve collective anxiety in times of crisis into four characteristics of collective persecution.

First, a crisis that makes everyone feel order is about to collapse; second, an accusation capable of arousing moral outrage, most commonly sexual transgression; third, the chosen person bears clear "victim markers," either a foreigner who can never truly assimilate into the mainstream ethnicity, or a king standing at the very top of the pyramid—and a Chinese big shot in a black leather jacket happens to be both; fourth, a citywide, unanimous moral execution.

Girard also wrote that after the scapegoat is expelled from the city and the panic temporarily subsides, the people in the city often begin to miss him, and even re-mythologize him.

On November 17, Nvidia will announce its latest quarterly earnings, which will be the company's first earnings call in 27 years as a public company without Jensen Huang present. The UK's Financial Times reported yesterday that Huang has privately discussed with those around him the possibility of returning.

One day later, on November 18, The New York Times' annual DealBook Summit will open as usual at the jazz hall of Lincoln Center in New York.

This is the newspaper's most grand vanity fair of the year, and also an excellent business: as early as 2022, a single ticket sold for $2,499. The host is The New York Times' star financial reporter Andrew Ross Sorkin, and sitting on stage are still the most powerful people in America.

Sorkin announced this year's list on October 13.

The list includes OpenAI CEO Sam Altman and President Greg Brockman, and Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella—the two companies The New York Times is currently suing in federal court; the list also includes David Ellison, who has just brought CBS and CNN into his family's fold, Vice President JD Vance, and Musk.

Three days earlier, on November 13, Musk had just announced on X that he would sign his name to the petition urging Jensen Huang to stay.

And under the spotlight at Lincoln Center, they will soon sit together again, chatting and laughing. Channel: International Hotspots. This content is published with the author's authorization; the views represent only the author and do not represent Huxiu's position. If you have objections or complaints about this manuscript, please contact tougao@huxiu.com. Everyone who is changing and wants to change the world is on the Huxiu APP[ ]]]

Source

Huxiu