“Double 11” Returns and Exchanges Face Hidden Barriers as AI-Related Consumer Complaints Rise Significantly
A 2026 “Double 11” consumer rights protection data report released by People’s Daily Online’s “People’s Complaints” platform shows a significant increase in AI-related complaints. Problems such as mechanical responses from AI customer service, difficulty reaching human agents, and contradictory answers have affected after-sales service. Some merchants also use unlabeled AI-generated product renderings and model images, as well as digital-human livestreams, potentially resulting in discrepancies between advertised and actual products and false advertising. Experts interviewed recommended establishing direct access to human customer service, fully preserving conversations and promises made during livestreams, and strictly enforcing rules requiring labels for AI-generated content.
Why read this
AI score 55
Complaint data reveal consumer risks such as difficulties transferring from AI customer service to human agents and unlabeled AI-generated images, while outlining governance approaches centered on preserving evidence and human-AI collaboration.
Topics
Body · AI translation
The 2026 “Double 11” shopping promotion has ended. Recently, People.cn’s “People’s Complaints” platform released a report on consumer rights protection data from the 2026 “Double 11” shopping festival. Its review of consumer complaints found that longstanding problems, such as refusing returns after inspection of products purchased with national subsidies, persist, while many new issues have emerged around AI (artificial intelligence) shopping guides and AI customer service.
The data report showed that complaints involving the fulfillment of after-sales obligations accounted for 30.2% of all complaints, with returns after unsealing and AI customer service among the issues most frequently raised by consumers.
Many consumers reported encountering difficulties when seeking returns or exchanges, particularly when their purchases involved national subsidies, leaving them in a “no-win situation over unsealing.” To verify eligibility for the national subsidy, recipients must open and inspect the product on the spot upon delivery. Once it has been unsealed, however, merchants refuse returns within the seven-day cooling-off period on the grounds that it “affects resale.”
A consumer surnamed Hong bought a laptop online. “When it arrived, it was inspected for national subsidy verification. Only after the courier left did I discover that the product delivered was not the same model I had purchased,” Hong said. She applied for a return, but the store refused to accept the return or issue a refund on the grounds that the product had been inspected and activated on site for the national subsidy. Other consumers reported that even when they had only opened the outer packaging and had not activated the devices, products such as computers and earphones still could not be returned or exchanged.
At the same time, restrictions involving paid benefit packages and mutually exclusive coupons also warrant caution. One consumer purchased a 7,999-yuan early-bird benefits package launched by an e-commerce platform for Apple’s first foldable-screen phone, mistakenly believing it was a deposit on the phone. Although none of the benefits had been used, a clause in small print on the product page stating that “pre-sale purchases cannot be returned or exchanged” prevented the consumer from obtaining a refund. Another consumer bought earphones from a physical store and found them defective immediately upon opening the box, but the accompanying coupon was not returned when the product was returned.
In addition, verbal promises such as “tenfold compensation for counterfeits,” “refundable after expiration” and “returns and exchanges guaranteed” made in livestreaming rooms and private online communities lack supporting evidence, while products not matching their descriptions, false advertising and merchants becoming unreachable after sales are common. One consumer purchased a travel package in a livestreaming room after the host promised that it could be refunded at any time and would remain valid for three years, but the merchant later refused a refund on the grounds that the after-sales period had expired. As transaction chains grow longer and the boundaries between channels become blurred, it becomes more difficult for consumers to produce evidence.
In response, Fu Xin, an associate research fellow at the Chinese Academy of International Trade and Economic Cooperation under the Ministry of Commerce, said that the concentration of after-sales disputes during this year’s “Double 11” shopping festival highlights an imbalance between rights and responsibilities in new consumption scenarios. “Conflicts between national subsidy verification and the seven-day cooling-off rule, as well as refund restrictions imposed through standard-form clauses in small print, essentially reflect poor coordination between promotional innovation, the implementation of subsidy policies and existing after-sales rules. As livestreaming e-commerce and online service consumption expand, disputes are no longer confined to disagreements over the quality of physical goods. Difficulties in producing evidence, ambiguous rules and unclear after-sales boundaries have become common bottlenecks, placing greater demands on platform governance and regulatory adaptation,” Fu said.
Fu recommended clarifying the boundaries of after-sales obligations, issuing special guidelines for products purchased with national subsidies, distinguishing policy-verification obligations from merchants’ return obligations, and providing clearer notices about supporting rules for price protection, coupons and benefits packages. At the same time, platform responsibilities should be reinforced. Platforms should automatically record and preserve verbal promises made during livestreams, implement security-deposit and advance-compensation mechanisms, strengthen constraints in cases involving diversion to private online channels or merchants becoming unreachable, and improve fast-track dispute resolution channels.
Notably, compared with previous “Double 11” shopping festivals, complaints involving AI increased significantly this year. Many consumers used AI to calculate discounts, compare specifications and select quality products, sparing themselves the trouble of staying up late to pore over shopping guides. At the same time, AI has also created new problems.
As new tools such as AI shopping guides and AI customer service enter consumer settings, problems including robotic responses, difficulty reaching human agents and contradictory answers have affected after-sales service. Some consumers reported that AI customer service was unable to resolve problems with their purchases. “I ordered a phone eligible for the national subsidy through an online platform, but the order was suddenly canceled. When I contacted customer service, I found that it was AI,” said a consumer surnamed Sun. The AI customer service repeatedly responded that it would “escalate the consumer’s case,” “ask a specialist to prioritize it” and “please keep your phone line available,” but never transferred him to a human agent.
In addition, problems involving AI-generated images and text are frequent. Many merchants use unlabelled, AI-generated renderings and model images that differ greatly from the actual products. They disregard the Measures for Labelling AI-Generated and Synthetic Content and fail to meet labelling obligations for digital-human livestreaming and AI-edited images, amounting to false advertising in disguised form.
Sun Yi, a professor at the School of Economics and Management of the University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, said that the more widely AI shopping guides and AI customer service are used, the more attention will be paid to questions such as whether AI responses can constitute transaction commitments, how incorrect responses should be corrected and whether human customer service can intervene promptly. “Consumers’ expectations of intelligent services will also shift from ‘fast responses’ to ‘effective resolution and accountability.’ Technology should make services more considerate, not create needless frustration. The key to addressing problems with AI customer service is to clarify the boundaries of rights and responsibilities so that technology truly returns to its service-oriented role instead of becoming a tool for merchants to shirk their responsibilities,” Sun said.
“A sound human-AI collaborative service mechanism should be established, with AI handling standardized inquiries first. For complex matters such as refunds and order disputes, a one-click channel providing direct access to human agents could be established, while complete conversation records should be retained so consumers do not have to submit the same evidence repeatedly,” Fu recommended. “The labelling system for AI-generated content must be strictly enforced to curb false advertising involving unlabelled AI-generated images and text. Finally, platforms need to automatically create and retain records of interactions with AI shopping guides and verbal promotions in AI livestreams, establishing a complete evidentiary chain for complaints. This will regulate and constrain the use of technology, allowing AI to optimize consumer decision-making while safeguarding the bottom line of consumer safety.”
AI Trends