AI News

Will Jensen Huang's personal controversy make Nvidia and the A-share supply chain pay the price?

HuxiuUpdated Nov 13 20:32

AI summary

After Jensen Huang's open letter acknowledging his personal controversy, Nvidia's board of directors launched an independent investigation, but the open letter had not yet appeared on November 5 when Nvidia fell 9.26% and its market value evaporated by more than 400 billion US dollars; that day the Nasdaq fell 5.52% and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell 12.25%, mainly due to market concerns about regulation and AI capital expenditure. Research shows that in the three days before and after a CEO negative event is exposed, the average abnormal decline is 4.06%, but Nvidia has no publicly announced successor, and Jensen Huang holds about 3.6% of the shares. Whether the A-share supply chain is damaged still depends on orders and customer structure: TFC Optical Communication supplies indirectly through Fabrinet, which accounts for 63.31% of its revenue; Zhongji Innolight's overseas revenue accounts for 94.82%, and its top five customers account for nearly 80%.

Body · AI translation

[[**Jensen Huang's personal scandal is a short-term disturbance for Nvidia, but the main cause of the November 5 plunge was market concerns over regulation and AI capital spending; whether Nvidia and the A-share supply chain are hurt still hinges on orders, deliveries and customer structure.**

**Key points**

**1. Jensen Huang is not the main cause of Nvidia's plunge**

When Nvidia fell 9.26% on November 5 and shed more than $400 billion in market value, the open letter had not yet appeared; over the same period the Nasdaq fell 5.52% and the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell 12.25%, with the market more worried about regulation and the sustainability of AI capital spending.

**2. Negative CEO events average an abnormal decline of 4.06%**

A study of 325 negative executive events shows an average abnormal decline of 1.62% in the three days around exposure; when the person involved is the CEO, this widens to 4.06%, versus only 0.32% for other executives. But some companies in the sample rose against the trend, so this cannot be applied directly to Nvidia.

**3. There is no ready replacement for Jensen Huang's absence**

He holds about 3.6% of the shares, while BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street together hold nearly 19%; the company's management relies heavily on his personal judgment, and there is no public successor. The board can launch an independent investigation, but an investigation does not equal solving the succession and order-continuity problems.

**4. Whether the supply chain pays depends on orders and customers**

Nvidia suppliers' capacity expansion schedules already run to 2027 and 2028, but expansion does not equal confirmed orders. TFC Optical supplies indirectly through Fabrinet, which accounts for 63.31% of its revenue; Zhongji Innolight's overseas revenue accounts for 94.82%, with its top five customers at nearly 80%. A-share reactions are mixed, and ultimately it still depends on revenue sources, customer budgets and orders materializing. 2026-11-09 09:50 Should Tech Pay for Jensen Huang's Affair? Zhiyuan Tongxue Quick Read

This article is from the WeChat public account: Wang Zhiyuan, author: Wang Zhiyuan

Good grief, last night Jensen Huang sent an open letter.

More than two hundred English words; the gist is that he had an affair and is willing to take full responsibility. There is nothing to argue about in this matter.

The trouble is that at almost the same time, Nvidia's board also issued a statement saying that recent reports indicated: Jensen Huang may become a target of foreign intelligence operations, and the company plans to have independent directors lead the matter and bring in outside lawyers to investigate it thoroughly.

The statement also stressed that there is currently no reason to believe that national security or company secrets have been compromised, and that it still has confidence in Jensen Huang and his management team.

In one night, this matter moved from the gossip pages to the financial pages. The question is: how much of a price will Jensen Huang's troubles actually make Nvidia pay?

...

First, look at the stock price.

On November 5, Nvidia fell 9.26%, evaporating more than $400 billion in market value in a single day. At that time, this open letter had not yet appeared.

That day the Nasdaq fell 5.52%, the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index fell 12.25%, and AMD and Micron also fell by double digits. Tech stocks fell across the board.

So this account cannot be placed directly on Jensen Huang's head.

Still, when a CEO has this kind of incident, how does the market usually react? Someone has actually studied it.

Cline and two other scholars counted 325 negative executive events and found that in the three days around the news exposure, the relevant companies on average saw an abnormal decline of 1.62%. By "abnormal," you can understand it as the extra decline after subtracting normal fluctuations such as the broader market.

If the person involved is the CEO, the average abnormal decline widens to 4.06%. For other executives, it is only 0.32%, which is not statistically significant.

Another study looked at 38 companies, and the result was somewhat counterintuitive. In the three days after the scandal was exposed, the average abnormal decline was 3.1%, but 11 of those companies actually recorded positive abnormal returns.

Even when executives get into trouble, stock price reactions really are different.

These numbers cannot be applied directly to Nvidia; the company is different, the nature of the matter is different, and the market environment is different too.

Now look at Nvidia's own stock price. It closed at $186.64 on November 6. On October 6 it was still around $239 at the close, a drop of 22% over the month.

For more than a month, the market has been revising expectations downward. Now Jensen Huang's personal scandal has emerged, and investors have to think one layer further.

If one day Jensen Huang really could not continue, what would happen to Nvidia? That is really hard to answer.

...

I checked, and Bernstein analyst Stacy Rasgon used a term: "key person risk"; in his view, Jensen Huang is almost the embodiment of Nvidia, and the company's long-term strategy and major decisions cannot be separated from him.

You can see it from his management style: Jensen Huang directly oversees dozens of subordinates, with very few management layers; when it comes to specific projects, he even bypasses middle managers and talks directly to engineers.

But the more a company gets used to revolving around one person, when that person is really absent, who takes over?

Jensen Huang's influence over the company is out of proportion to his shareholding.

According to available materials, he holds about 3.6% of Nvidia's shares; BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street together hold nearly 19%, more than five times his stake.

In terms of equity, he does not hold as much as these institutions combined. But in terms of where the company is headed, Jensen Huang's weight cannot be calculated by shareholding ratio.

Nvidia also has a board of directors; most of its 11 directors are independent directors, with audit, nomination and corporate governance, compensation and other committees below it.

If the board has indeed launched an independent investigation, the governance procedures that should be followed must be followed.

The company says externally that this matter will not slow Nvidia down and that Jensen Huang will continue as CEO without interruption.

But a process can solve an investigation problem; it may not solve a succession problem. Nvidia has not publicly named a clear successor. Jensen Huang has also said before that he hopes to keep working for decades more.

For a company with a market value of $4.5 trillion, the board can investigate the CEO, but it is very hard to find another Jensen Huang in a short time.

Still, a CEO running into trouble does not necessarily mean he has to leave the company.

In 2018, Musk was sued by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission over a tweet about taking the company private. The two sides later settled; he stepped down as Tesla chairman and could not serve as chairman for three years, but he kept the CEO position.

Tesla later continued to grow as well. Of course, the two matters are different in nature and cannot be used to extrapolate by analogy.

The real question is: if Jensen Huang one day can no longer steer the ship, do those orders and capacity arrangements scheduled into 2027 and 2028 still count?

……

I checked along Nvidia's supply chain and found that the more realistic problem right now is still whether the chips can be delivered on time.

On October 21, Nvidia gathered six suppliers in Berlin to expand production together, covering packaging, substrates, testing and other links. Some planned to raise capacity to two or three times the original level, and some were even preparing to expand more than tenfold.

Jensen Huang said at the time that demand was too great and capacity was the bottleneck.

That is not hard to understand. TSMC's advanced packaging capacity is tight, and HBM high-bandwidth memory is also in short supply. To ensure delivery, Nvidia paid suppliers in advance and pushed some capacity arrangements out to 2027 and 2028.

The money has been invested and factories are being expanded. As long as customer demand remains, the supply chain has the incentive to keep delivering, but a distinction must be made here: expansion plans are not the same as confirmed orders.

Looking further at the A-share side, the situation gets even more interesting.

I went through TFC Optical Communication's customer disclosures and found a detail that is easy to overlook: between it and Nvidia, there is still Fabrinet.

Fabrinet is an optical manufacturing company listed in the U.S. and TFC Optical Communication's largest customer; over the past three years, its share of TFC Optical Communication's revenue rose from 53.61% to 61.69%, and then to 63.31%.

Nvidia is Fabrinet's customer, and TFC Optical Communication supplies optical communications-related products to Fabrinet.

The relationship here is much more complicated than the phrase "Nvidia concept stock."

Fabrinet is responsible for manufacturing and assembling optical products, while upstream suppliers provide related components. Work such as optical path alignment and coupling precision has very high yield requirements, and suppliers cannot simply be swapped out at will.

However, high customer concentration also carries risks in turn.

If Fabrinet reduces purchases, TFC Optical Communication could be affected. As for how big the impact will be and how long it will take to reach revenue, that still depends on specific orders and inventory arrangements.

In the first half of this year, TFC Optical Communication's active optical device revenue fell 19.57% year on year. According to the company's explanation in investor relations activities, supply of some bottleneck materials was tight, which affected the delivery pace.

You see, even if downstream demand is decent, a shortage of one key upstream material can still affect revenue.

As for the claim circulating online that "Nvidia Mellanox optical engines account for 90% to 95% of supply," I could not find any basis in the company's existing disclosure materials that directly supports this ratio.

Zhongji Innolight is another situation.

It mainly serves overseas cloud vendors. In the first half of this year, overseas revenue accounted for 94.82%, and its top five customers contributed nearly 80% of revenue.

On October 23, the company also specifically reminded: "Order demand guidance is not the same as confirmed revenue."

A cloud vendor telling you how much product it will need next year, and how many orders are finally signed, how much is delivered, and how much revenue is recognized, are several different things.

Zhongji Innolight's profit grew very fast in the first three quarters, but tight component supply is also affecting market expectations. In early November, Goldman Sachs also cut its profit forecasts for the company's next three years.

The two companies require looking at different things. TFC Optical Communication requires watching Fabrinet's purchases, while Zhongji Innolight requires watching overseas cloud vendors' capital expenditure and also whether components can keep up.

Recently, Microsoft adjusted some external computing power leasing arrangements, which also offers an angle for observation: customers will reconsider chip specifications, delivery schedules and project costs, and the computing power originally planned to be leased may not all materialize.

Jensen Huang is certainly important, but companies in Nvidia's industrial chain ultimately still have to make money through orders and delivery.

……

Speaking of A-shares, I also looked at the market on November 6. The previous day, U.S. tech stocks fell sharply. On the A-share side, the Shanghai Composite Index fell 1.1%, and the ChiNext Index fell 3.96%.

But if you look closely, you will find the declines were very different.

Zhongji Innolight fell 9.19%, and Dongshan Precision hit the limit down. On the other side, the Huawei computing power index fell 1.94%, while SMIC actually rose 0.19% and China Mobile rose 3.24%.

All are labeled with the word "tech," yet their performance differed by a wide margin.

But SMIC and China Mobile have different business structures, and investors consider different things.

Still, one cannot conclude based on a single day's gains and losses that funds are lining up stocks according to the share of overseas revenue. Valuation levels, fund holdings and the companies' own news can all affect that day's performance.

But at least it can be seen that when the decline in U.S. tech stocks transmitted to A-shares, companies reacted differently.

Some effects come very quickly. When U.S. stocks plunge overnight, related A-share sectors adjust the next day; it may simply be that investors worry future growth will not be as good and first push valuations down.

As for whether the business has actually deteriorated, that still needs to be seen later.

If overseas cloud vendors continue to increase capital expenditure and orders are delivered as usual, a short-term stock price decline does not mean the company will immediately earn less; conversely, if customers begin to cut budgets and delay purchases, the impact may only gradually show up in later financial reports.

After all, whether domestic substitution can be delivered ultimately depends on whether the products are usable and whether customers are willing to buy.

There are still several time points worth noting next.

On November 11, Jensen Huang is to reply to Congress—whether he will go or not; after the market close on November 17, Nvidia will release its third-quarter report; on November 18, there will be a closed-door congressional briefing, the day after the earnings report.

What I want to see more is the earnings report.

Whether orders have changed, whether gross margin can be defended, and what management says about the next few quarters—these things are closer to Nvidia's business itself than guessing how many points a personal controversy will knock off the stock price.

If the investigation produces new substantive progress, it could also change the market's judgment on corporate governance. As for whether the next U.S. stock market open will rise or fall, no one can say for sure right now.

Back to the question at the beginning: should A-share tech companies pay for Jensen Huang's troubles? I think there is no need to rush to pay on their behalf—they have already been miserable recently—but my word does not count.

Flip through the financial report of the company in your hands, see where revenue comes from, who the largest customer is, and whether orders have truly landed; these may be more critical.

In my view, the news about Jensen Huang may just be a trigger in this great tide of technology.

Has published 446 articles on Huxiu. This content comes from the internet, original link; the views represent only the author and do not represent Huxiu's position. If there is any copyright issue, please contact hezuo@huxiu.com, and we will verify and handle it promptly. Everyone who is changing and wants to change the world is on the Huxiu APP[ ]]]

Source

Huxiu