Apple's New Rules Lead to Removal of Five Apps from Top 10 AI Companion Revenue Rankings, Industry Faces Compliance-Driven Reshuffle
Affected by Apple's updated review rules in October, five leading AI companion apps, including "Tipsy" and "Zeta," were removed from the iOS App Store. These apps previously occupied five of the top ten spots in the revenue rankings. The new rules explicitly prohibit generating non-consensual intimate imagery and hiding harmful features, with violators facing account bans. This move has forced developers to tighten content moderation and abandon quick monetization models reliant on NSFW content, while also allowing some competitors, such as "Heyyyy," to benefit from a traffic windfall.
Why read this
AI score 55
This article outlines the chain reaction caused by Apple's new rules leading to the removal of several top AI companion apps, revealing the commercial pains of the sector's transition from reliance on NSFW content toward compliance.
Topics
Body · AI translation
Today, the mobile AI companion app market has essentially become a home turf battle between Chinese and Korean teams. According to SensorTower data, the top ten apps by revenue are almost exclusively from Chinese/Chinese-heritage teams or have Korean backgrounds; it remains to be seen who will have the last laugh.
Revenue figures only include in-app purchases (IAP).
Currently, Chinese developers lead with a significant advantage. The top-ranked "Tipsy" is in a league of its own, generating RMB 130 million per month—nearly double that of second-place "Zeta." Two other dark horses emerged: the newly ranked "Tizz," reportedly developed by Zuoyebang; and "Heyyyy," whose team pivoted from the gaming industry and also includes core members of Chinese heritage.
Korean developers are closing in fast. Wrtn alone has three products in the upper ranks, localized for the US, South Korea, and Japan markets, collectively earning over RMB 90 million per month.
However, it is too early to say the landscape for AI companion apps is settled. First, the market is far from saturated; current competition focuses on users in the US, Japan, and South Korea, leaving many other markets untapped. Second, the real test may have just begun—with Apple's new regulations for AI applications taking effect in October, violations could result in delisting and account bans. What waves will this cause? Teams across the board are likely watching nervously, feeling both anxious and concerned.
Five of the Top Ten Revenue Apps Have Been Delisted!
The impact seems more severe than anticipated. While media previously reported that two leading apps, "Tipsy" and "PolyBuzz," were removed from iOS, the actual scope is broader—"Zeta," "Chai," and "Tizz" have also quietly disappeared from iOS. In other words, five out of the top ten AI companion apps by revenue have been delisted at once! (Note: These apps have largely been removed from iOS in their primary markets, though they remain downloadable in a few regions.)
No official statement has yet explained these removals, but speculation widely points to recent iOS policy updates.
The story begins in January this year, when nonprofit organization TTP released a report exposing numerous AI undressing apps in the Apple and Google stores, such as those generating explicit images of real people without consent. Statistics showed 47 such apps on Google and 55 on Apple (with 38 available on both platforms), collectively generating USD 117 million in revenue (per AppMagic), with platforms indirectly benefiting through commission fees.
In April, TTP followed up reporting that despite both platforms explicitly banning "nudification" apps, search and advertising pathways still directed users toward them. By July, San Francisco officials demanded Apple remove eight products capable of generating non-consensual intimate images. Subsequently, controversies involving Grok and others occurred...
Under public opinion and regulatory pressure, Apple updated its review guidelines on October 16, drawing two red lines: first, prohibiting apps from generating "non-consensual intimate imagery" (including AI-generated images); second, banning apps with hidden or undocumented features (including those falsely representing their purpose during review and revealing harmful functions like "nudification" after approval). If verified, consequences extend beyond delisting to account bans—potentially prompting more vendors to use shell accounts to evade risks.
The AI companion sector indeed has cases where NSFW content drives monetization (Note: NSFW, not safe for work, broadly refers to content unsuitable for public viewing, including explicit sexual suggestions, sexualized images, borderline interactions, and adult content). This path is clever and easier to succeed with. This explains why some non-NSFW apps, despite higher download and active user numbers, generate less in-app purchase revenue than NSFW/dating apps.
This premise assumes platform tolerance, which is clearly impossible. Looking at the timeline, "PolyBuzz" was the first to disappear from iOS, delisted on October 15. In hindsight, this served as a signal; within the following two to three weeks, several competitors were also successively removed.
Reactions from various parties have been subtle.
So far, only "Chai" has responded publicly, briefly mentioning that the iOS version is undergoing optimization and cannot be downloaded from iOS, though existing installations remain functional.
While apps continue to operate normally, updates pose problems. Users report receiving update notifications that lead to missing store pages; moreover, each iOS system update increases the likelihood of failures for unmaintained older versions.
Controversy also surrounds "Chai's" recently implemented mandatory content filtering mechanism (forcing NSFW filters). Users complain that moderation is overly strict and one-size-fits-all, harming the experience, and request an optional toggle switch. The official stance remains firm, stating they will never offer "unrestricted AI chatbots," citing global regulatory requirements for AI content filtering and Apple's clear restrictions on UGC, meaning unfiltered versions are not an option. This response received hundreds of downvotes in the community—while users may understand the reasoning, resentment is evident.
Meanwhile, "PolyBuzz" remained completely silent throughout. Its official Instagram account was flooded with users asking why it could no longer be found on iOS. Discussion threads also appeared on Reddit, where many commenters were baffled. Some users simply attributed this to Apple cracking down on AI apps. Only a few pointed out that it might involve borderline content, with some citing Character.AI as an example of an app that "continued operating thanks to strict moderation," though they may not have known that Character.AI recently filed for bankruptcy protection—according to Reuters, Character.AI still has about 12 million active users but loses $8 to 9 million per month due to computing power and personnel costs.
As for the most profitable app, "Tipsy," its revenue has not fluctuated significantly in the short term, but long-term pressure is considerable. Its daily active users were already low, and its revenue volume relied heavily on high-spending users (big R). Once NSFW content is strictly regulated, life will likely be difficult under the existing monetization model.
The team must be quite troubled. Internally, they issued an announcement acknowledging that this delisting had a significant impact. Going forward, they will tighten content moderation, modify some launched character images to comply with new regulations, and expand the scope of review to cover content involving minors and copyright infringement. The officials hope creators will focus on storylines, character development, and immersive interactions, avoiding overly sexualized or sexually suggestive creations.
It is foreseeable that the adjusted "Tipsy" will likely face user churn and reduced revenue.
This series of events has brought several issues to the forefront: Can AI companions make money without relying on borderline content? (Not necessarily, but it may not be as quick or easy as gray-area tactics.) Apple has already taken action; will Google follow suit? Can AI apps strengthen moderation without harming the UGC experience?
These problems are difficult to solve in the short term. But one thing everyone knows clearly: the shortcut of quickly monetizing via NSFW content in the past will likely be overturned. Some netizens believe this impact is limited to mobile devices. One netizen stated that, based on their observations, most developers of content-sharing apps prefer the Web side. The true advantage of app stores lies in better external marketing and ready-made smooth payment channels. However, this ecosystem is now restricted everywhere, and content sharing has been severely curtailed unless your app is entirely SFW (safe for work, suitable for all ages with no sensitive content) and has maximum moderation controls.
Who benefited from this wave of delistings?
While this wave of delistings served as a wake-up call for peers, it also triggered some chain reactions.
For competitors, the moment when top apps "disappeared" was undoubtedly a good opportunity to grab users, which should not be missed. Observations show that indeed several competing products benefited.
A rather bizarre case is a new product called "Tipsy AI," which took the opportunity to launch on iOS, seemingly leveraging similar names and logos to ride on "Tipsy's" popularity. Users who searched for it thought it was the same app and downloaded it, resulting in over 7,000 downloads and tens of thousands of yuan in revenue in a short time.
"Tizz" fared worse; just as its momentum began to rise, it encountered an iOS delisting and has now dropped out of the monthly revenue TOP 10 (statistics period: October 18 to November 16). Its position has been replaced by "Popia" from Beijing Yuanshi Technology.
"Emochi" and "Heyyyy" also clearly captured this wave of traffic. Recently, both apps saw increases in iOS downloads, with revenues rising accordingly.
iOS download trends (Source: SensorTower)
Among them, "Heyyyy" surged to No. 34 on the US iOS Entertainment Grossing Chart. Its team is unique, having transitioned from the gaming industry. Public information shows the company has three co-founders and directors, two of whom are founders of the mobile game company A Thinking Ape, and one named Yao Zhenwang, a graduate of the University of Science and Technology of China, who worked at iFlytek and Motorola before joining A Thinking Ape in 2010, holding positions such as software engineer, team lead, and VP of Growth.
A Thinking Ape has accumulated over a decade of experience in strong social games, with representative titles like "Party in My Dorm" and "Kingdoms at HF," both operating for more than 10 years and generating hundreds of millions in cumulative revenue. The company was acquired by European gaming giant Embracer Group for $105 million in 2020, when it had only 82 employees. Later, the two founders and Yao Zhenwang chose to leave, and now they have come together again to venture into AI social networking startups. Based on "Heyyyy's" performance, this start is quite promising.
"Heyyyy"
Overall, there are winners and losers. But then again, current safety does not guarantee future safety. After all, this round of platform self-review is not targeting any single company or product but marks the beginning of normalized tightening. Ultimately, manufacturers need to look long-term, thinking about how to deepen content and improve experiences so that users willingly pay, rather than betting on short-term benefits.
This article comes from the WeChat public account "Game New Knowledge" (ID: youxixinzhi), author: Sunset Flyer, published with authorization from 36Kr.
AI Trends