On the Eve of the AI Bubble Bursting: Earnings Beat Expectations Yet Stocks Plunge, AI Coding Brings No Incremental Revenue
The Nasdaq fell 2.86%, Intel plunged 28.58% in a single day, its biggest drop in forty years, Google fell 12.64% and shed nearly $500 billion, and SanDisk fell 13.47% despite beating earnings expectations. AI Coding has caused a surge in code supply, but product revenue has not grown in tandem; Token prices have fallen 50-100 times this year, and Google AI Mode giving direct answers has caused Reddit's weekly search visits to drop by more than 1 million and its stock price to fall 29%. ByteDance earned about $50 billion last year and plans to spend up to $70 billion this year building AI infrastructure.
Topics
Body · AI translation
[[**AI giants' earnings beat expectations yet still plunge, market fears bubble bursting; more critically, AI boosts productivity but creates no obvious incremental value, and also compresses the transaction chain and consumption cycle, while the giants still pour cash heavily into AI infrastructure.**
**Key points**
**1. Earnings beat expectations yet still plunge, bubble fears heat up**
The Nasdaq fell 2.86%, Intel fell 28.58% for its biggest one-day drop in forty years, Google fell 12.64% wiping out nearly $500 billion, and SanDisk beat expectations yet still fell 13.47%.
**2. AI Coding brings no obvious incremental revenue**
AI makes the supply of code and products explode, but intelligence is no longer scarce, and the prices of tokens, products and jobs are falling; developers have more products but find it hard to make money, and it is more like "pleasing oneself."
**3. AI compresses middlemen and the transaction cycle**
Google AI Mode gives answers directly, Reddit's weekly search visits fell by more than 1 million and its stock fell 29%; relay stations have razor-thin profits because token prices have plunged.
**4. The giants bet their profits and cash on AI infrastructure**
Microsoft offered voluntary buyouts to 60,000 employees, ByteDance earned about $50 billion last year and plans to spend up to $70 billion this year building AI infrastructure; rising hardware prices drag down phone and PC sales.
**5. The present resembles the eve of an AI bubble**
Today is Saturday, October 31, 2026.
US markets just closed on Friday, US time.
The Nasdaq fell 2.86%, which is not such a terrifying number, yet the internet is full of wailing.
Intel fell 28.58% on Friday, its biggest one-day drop in forty years. Its third-quarter EPS was 0.52, far above the market expectation of 0.40.
Just yesterday, Google fell 12.64% to close at $283.82, its worst day since its 2004 listing. Nearly $500 billion of market value evaporated in a single day. Yet its revenue missed market expectations by only 0.2% to 0.4%. Its cloud revenue doubled, and its search query growth was the highest in five years.
SanDisk's revenue rose 23% quarter over quarter, adjusted EPS was $49.51, up more than 40-fold year over year, and it holds $91.1 billion in signed orders. Earnings beat expectations, and the stock still fell 13.47%.
This article does not constitute any investment advice, and investment is not what I want to talk about today.
This year, what has affected us most is probably the rise in memory and flash storage prices.
Rising hardware prices directly resulted in declining PC and phone sales.
Memory already accounts for 40% of the cost of Apple phones. The standard iPhone is simply not being released.
The new iPad mini sells for 5,499, but it comes with only 128GB of flash storage, not even enough for two large games.
Many Android makers have also stopped releasing low-end thousand-yuan phones.
Intel forecasts that the PC market will shrink 12% in 2026 and another 10% in 2027, with the downturn continuing.
At least as of this point on October 31, 2026, I have not seen it.
If there must be an exception, the only exception is Hongguo Short Dramas, but that matter is also very strange, and I will discuss it at the end of the article.
I know this conclusion will be rebutted by many people, so let us look at the strongest area of AI, Coding. AI Coding is so strong, how can you say it has not created incremental value?
Yes, AI Coding capability is beyond doubt. Every software company has boosted its Coding productivity because of AI, and every company's code volume is exploding, with one year matching the past ten.
But productivity does not equal value.
AI Coding boosts productivity 10-fold, but it has not increased product revenue 10-fold, and even 2-fold increases are very, very rare.
This principle becomes easy to understand if we swap in something else.
Yunnan's blueberry output this year grew 39% over last year, but prices fell 50% from last year.
The official conclusion was: "A large volume of fresh fruit flooded into the market in a concentrated way, and the change in supply and demand structure led to a cliff-like drop in prices."
Supply increased, but revenue does not necessarily increase, because things sold cheaper.
Economics is just that ruthless: only scarcity has value, and humans pay for scarcity.
Price is determined by supply and demand; if demand is unchanged, the more supply there is, the cheaper it gets.
Last year, you ran a business and could earn $1 million a year.
This year you have more powerful AI, and you think, great, productivity has improved, so this year I can earn $10 million.
But do not forget that AI lets your competitors build your business in a day, so the number of your competitors has increased 10-fold. The result is fiercer competition, and consumers get cheaper goods and services.
Consuming 10 times the tokens, producing 10 times the products, working 10 times as hard.
And still only barely maintaining the balance of value.
Products come out one after another.
But did they make money? Not one of them.
I asked my friends whether your vibe coding counts as save time or kill time, and everyone said kill time.
No wonder some people say that the essence of AI is neither 2B nor 2C, but 2me—just to make yourself happy.
The basic principle of economics is about transactions. Transactions make everyone's life better.
A person obtains money through transactions and goes to consume, so others obtain money, and they go to consume, and so on in an endless cycle.
Even the logic of content consumption has changed.
Reddit just experienced its worst day since going public today, with its stock price falling 29%.
On the conference call, Reddit CEO Steve Huffman summed up the reason simply:
Google's AI Mode now gives answers directly, and no one clicks links anymore.
For the past 25 years, the internet's protocol has been this:
Websites provide content for Google, and Google sends users back to the websites.
But now AI Mode summarizes it, users get the result directly, and they leave.
The number of daily users entering websites in the United States has fallen 2% over the past year, the first decline since Reddit went public in 2024.
Reddit is just a microcosm. It is widely recognized as the most human-feeling community, and even it has been affected this way, let alone other websites.
When the nest is overturned, how can any eggs remain unbroken?
But aren't relay stations still making pretty good money? How can you say there are no middlemen?
From Claude Opus 4.5 to DeepSeek Flash 4.1, the price of tokens for completing the same tasks has dropped 50-100 times this year, and it is foreseeable that it will drop at least another 10 times next year.
Now there are few relay stations still offering low-priced models like Luna. A friend who runs a relay station told me that their revenue still looks okay, but after deducting costs, there isn't much profit left.
Tokens are too cheap, already cheaper than the cost of relay servers.
There was another big event this week: Microsoft opened voluntary departure buyouts to 60,000 employees, more than a quarter of its total workforce.
Everyone knows this is a gentle form of layoffs.
Has Microsoft run into a problem? Why does it want to lay off a quarter of its employees?
Speaking of this, we have to talk about ByteDance's big closed loop, Hongguo Short Dramas.
It must be said that Hongguo is an even more formidable product than Douyin—short dramas for everyone, suitable for all ages.
Fanqie Novel's text + Seedance's video generation + Juliang Engine's intelligent advertising + Hongguo's DAU and time spent.
ByteDance earned about $50 billion last year, and this year it plans to spend up to $70 billion building AI infrastructure.
Looking through history, in every technology cycle, a technology first goes through a bubble, then a big crash to deflate the bubble, and only then do people apply it to places with real value.
This is the cycle, and behind the cycle is human nature.
Technology keeps changing, but human nature never changes.
From ChatGPT's release in November 2022 to today, AI is about to complete a full four years.
Anthropic is going public next month, and many people say that will be the peak of the AI bubble.
What do you think?
Note: This article is processed and organized based only on public information. The author does not understand investing at all, and this article does not constitute any investment advice.
This article comes from the WeChat public account: Orange AI, author: Orange AI AI Industry Signal Channel: Frontier Technology. This content is published with the author's authorization. The views represent only the author and do not represent Huxiu's position. If you have any objections or complaints about this manuscript, please contact tougao@huxiu.com. Everyone who is changing and wants to change the world is on the Huxiu APP[ ]
AI Trends