Experts explain how AI creation income should be taxed: the key lies in economic substance; a "virtual cloak" is not a tax-avoidance shield
Wang Liangliang, a professor at Nanjing University Business School, and other fiscal and tax experts pointed out that determining the nature of AI creators' income depends on the substance of the business: independent personal creation is generally taxed as remuneration for labor services or royalties, while those registered as individual industrial and commercial households and operating continuously are taxed on business income, and the latter may deduct reasonable expenses such as AI tool subscription fees and computing power service fees. Platforms paying revenue shares to AI creators have a withholding obligation, while digital human streamers follow the principle of "whoever earns the income pays the tax"; digital humans themselves do not have the status of an independent taxpayer.
Topics
Body · AI translation
Add new crowdsourcing testing promotional copy Add new crowdsourcing testing promotional copy end Add App-exclusive traffic guidance
Currently, artificial intelligence-generated content (AIGC) technology is accelerating its iteration, and new business forms such as AI painting, AI video, AI writing, and digital human livestreaming are flourishing, giving rise to a large number of "AI creators." Among them are full-time prompt engineers and AI painters, part-time content creators, and multi-channel network (MCN) agencies that operate digital human streamers, among others. As income from AI creation grows rapidly, a series of tax-related issues have followed: Is the income of AI creators remuneration for labor services or business income? Are platforms required to withhold and remit taxes when paying out creative revenue shares? And who should pay taxes on the income of digital human streamers? Reporters interviewed some experts in the fiscal and tax field on these questions. ▲File photo, image source: Tuchong Creative
"No matter how new business forms take shape, the principles of statutory taxation and taxable capacity will not change—taxable income must be declared in accordance with the law, and the key to determining the nature of income lies in its economic substance," said Wang Liangliang, a professor at the Business School of Nanjing University. At present, with the coordinated efforts of tax big data, smart supervision, and the tax-related information reporting system for internet platforms, tax order in the AI creation field is being continuously standardized, and "virtual cloaks" are no longer a shield for tax avoidance.
How should the nature of income be defined?
It depends on the substance of the business
Wang Liangliang pointed out that the income of AI creators mainly comes from platform creative revenue sharing, customized creation service fees, prompt and model training service fees, and digital human streamer operation income, among others. The key to determining the nature of such income lies in whether the creator conducts activities in an "operating" manner.
Wang Liangliang further explained that if a creator independently engages in AI creation activities as an individual, has not registered as an individual industrial and commercial household or a sole proprietorship enterprise, and the income mainly depends on personal skills and labor, tax should generally be calculated as "income from remuneration for labor services" or "income from royalties"; if the creator has registered an individual industrial and commercial household or a studio with the market supervision department, has a fixed place of business, employs personnel, and operates continuously, and the income has obvious operating characteristics, tax should be calculated as "business income."
"Once the nature of income is determined in accordance with the law, the rules for deducting costs and expenses are also determined accordingly," Wang Liangliang pointed out. Under the Individual Income Tax Law and its implementing regulations, income from remuneration for labor services and income from royalties is subject to the statutory proportional expense deduction rule, and actual creation expenditures may not be deducted on a reimbursement basis. Therefore, if an AI creator substantively meets the conditions for income from remuneration for labor services, various creation cost expenditures such as AI tool subscription fees, computing power service fees, and computing power leasing fees may not be deducted on a reimbursement basis in such stages as withholding and prepayment and the annual comprehensive settlement. If an AI creator substantively meets the conditions for business income, reasonable expenditures related to production and operation (such as AI tool subscription fees, computing power service fees, computing power leasing fees, and digital human production service fees) may be deducted when calculating taxable income, but lawful and valid vouchers must be obtained.
It should be made clear that the distinction in the nature of individual income tax income does not change value-added tax (VAT) obligations. The VAT Law provides that units and individuals that carry out taxable transactions such as providing services for consideration and transferring intangible assets within the territory are VAT taxpayers. Natural persons and enterprises whose annual VAT-taxable sales do not exceed 5 million yuan may, as small-scale taxpayers, apply the simplified tax calculation at a 3% levy rate (reduced to 1% before December 31, 2027); except under special circumstances, enterprises whose annual VAT-taxable sales exceed 5 million yuan shall register as general taxpayers and apply the general tax calculation method. "In practice, AI painting, AI writing, AI video, digital human livestreaming, and the transfer of digital human images, model results, and the like, regardless of whether they are recognized as remuneration for labor services or business income for individual income tax purposes, shall be subject to VAT calculation and payment in accordance with regulations as long as a VAT-taxable transaction occurs," Wang Liangliang specifically noted. Small-scale taxpayers that pay tax monthly and have monthly sales of less than 100,000 yuan (exclusive), pay tax quarterly and have quarterly sales of less than 300,000 yuan (exclusive), or pay tax per transaction and have sales of less than 1,000 yuan per transaction (day) (exclusive) are exempt from VAT.
"It can thus be seen that the tax obligation depends on the economic substance of the transaction for consideration and has nothing to do with the name given to the income or the entity in which it is placed; attempts to convert the nature of income by setting up entities, changing names, and the like can neither evade VAT obligations nor avoid individual income tax," Wang Liangliang emphasized. In practice, some AI creators register multiple individual industrial and commercial households or "shell" studios to convert income that should belong to remuneration for labor services into business income and improperly apply deemed collection. This is essentially the same as the tax evasion behavior of "converting the nature of income" by internet streamers previously investigated and dealt with by tax authorities, and is a serious tax-related illegal act.
Platforms' withholding and remittance obligations cannot be shirked
"According to the Individual Income Tax Law and relevant provisions, when a platform pays creative revenue shares or service fees to AI creators, the payer is the withholding agent and shall withhold and remit individual income tax in accordance with the law," pointed out Zhang Fan, a professor at the School of Accounting of Nanjing University of Finance and Economics and a researcher at the Jiangsu Institute of Modern Fiscal and Tax Governance. In practice, some platforms fail to perform withholding and remittance obligations on the grounds that "creators are independent operators," or withhold and remit only on part of the income; these are all illegal acts.
"At present, the income data of platform operators has been fully incorporated into supervision, and platforms' withholding and remittance responsibilities have been further tightened," Zhang Fan emphasized. Since the Provisions on the Reporting of Tax-Related Information by Internet Platform Enterprises took effect last June, internet platform enterprises must, in accordance with regulations, report to the competent tax authorities tax-related information such as the identity information and income information of platform operators and practitioners. The Announcement on Several Matters Concerning Internet Platform Enterprises' Handling of Withholding Declarations and Agency Declarations for Platform Practitioners, issued in the same year, clarified matters concerning the application of tax policies to platform practitioners.
Zhang Fan further pointed out that in VAT collection and administration, platforms likewise bear a coordinating responsibility. The Announcement of the State Taxation Administration on Several Matters Concerning Internet Platform Enterprises' Handling of Withholding Declarations and Agency Declarations for Platform Practitioners clarifies that a platform may, after obtaining the written consent of a practitioner, handle VAT and surtax declaration on the practitioner's behalf, and the practitioner may, in accordance with regulations, enjoy preferential policies such as exemption for small-scale taxpayers with monthly sales of less than 100,000 yuan (exclusive) and a reduced levy rate of 1% in place of the 3% rate; where a practitioner's cumulative service income over 12 consecutive months exceeds 5 million yuan, the platform shall guide the practitioner to register as a market entity and declare and pay VAT on their own. For natural persons who do not go through a platform and directly provide R&D, software, design, consulting, radio, film and television program production, cultural, or educational services to domestic entities, starting from November 1, 2026, the domestic entity paying the price shall withhold and remit VAT and surtaxes in accordance with the Measures for the Administration of Domestic Entities' Withholding and Remittance of VAT for Natural Persons.
Digital human streamers are not a tax blind spot
Digital human streamers are an important application scenario of AIGC, and there are usually three operating models. First, an enterprise's own digital human, operated by enterprise employees, with livestreaming income belonging to the enterprise, which pays VAT and corporate income tax, while employees receive wages and salaries; second, the "inner person" (the real person behind a virtual streamer or digital human who operates and performs as the character) signed by an MCN agency, with the digital human image belonging to the MCN agency and the "inner person" receiving remuneration for services or wages and salaries; third, a digital human operated by an individual, with income belonging to the individual.
"Whichever model it is, the core principle is 'whoever obtains the income pays the tax,'" pointed out Ma Delin, a professor at the School of Accounting of Nanjing Audit University. Under the current legal framework, a digital human itself does not have independent legal personality and generally cannot serve as a taxpayer; its income must be attributed to the legal entity that actually controls or operates it, and that entity bears the corresponding tax obligations.
"Some MCN agencies exploit the 'virtual' characteristics of digital human streamers to spread income across multiple shell entities or personal accounts to conceal income, or to falsely list expenses by fabricating digital human production costs; these are all current priorities of supervision," Ma Delin warned. The Opinions on Further Regulating Profit-Making Behavior in Online Livestreaming to Promote the Healthy Development of the Industry, issued in March 2022, clearly stipulate that enterprises and individual studios established by online livestreaming publishers shall set up account books in accordance with regulations, and in principle income tax shall be levied on them by means of audit-based assessment. As a new form of online livestreaming, digital human streamers are likewise subject to the above requirements.
"The healthy development of new business forms needs to be based on paying taxes in accordance with the law," Wang Liangliang suggested. AI creators should strengthen their compliance awareness, proactively study tax laws and regulations, accurately determine the nature of their income and their VAT tax obligations, and handle tax declarations in accordance with the law. For creators with relatively high income and stable business, they may, under the premise of compliance, register as individual industrial and commercial households or studios, establish sound financial accounting systems, and standardize cost deductions; platform enterprises should earnestly perform their withholding and remittance obligations and truthfully report creators' income information to tax authorities; MCN agencies should standardize the income accounting and cost management of digital human streamers and must not use the characteristics of new business forms to evade tax obligations.
Red Star News chief reporter Wu Yang
Editor Zhang Li
Reviewer He Xianju Statement: Exclusive article of Sina.com, reproduction without authorization is prohibited. tech_web_article_v2015_block_bottom Non-targeted 300*250 button 17/09 wenjing begin
Non-targeted 300*250 button end