Red and Black List of Four Personal Agents: Grok Bot, Muse, Claude Duet, and ChatGPT Dots Tested by Division of Labor
English text is being prepared.
Peter Yang updated his tested red and black list of four personal agents: Grok Bot excels at real-time X data research but its email feature is unusable; Muse is free and stands out in offline business phone capabilities but is slightly weaker in raw intelligence; Claude Duet has the strongest proactivity and base-model intelligence but its research preview lacks browser takeover; ChatGPT Dots can inherit historical assets but still has bugs and slow voice connections. He connects no more than 4 agents to his personal email at the same time.
View original postHere's my updated review of each personal agent: 1. Grok Bot Pros: A team of bots is the easiest to understand. Free X access is amazing for research. Voice mode and the new Pages feature are great. Cons: Email feature doesn't really work. 2. Muse Pros: Free, best consumer UX, most meme-worthy avatar, and business calling is amazing. Cons: Muse Wonder is good but Opus/Astra is better. 3. Claude Duet Pros: Most proactive out of the box. Feels polished and simple to use. Arguably the best model behind it. Cons: Missing some features in research preview, like being able to drive its browser. 4. ChatGPT Dots Pros: Works inside ChatGPT, so it can drive all your cloud and local threads. Cons: Much better than at launch but still buggy. Voice mode is slow to connect. I've also tried Instinct and some of the other agents, but I don't want more than 4 at a time connected to my email. 📌 Don't miss my full Claude Duet review here for everything that it can do: https://t.co/EK28ETwWjD
View original
Here's my updated review of each personal agent: 1. Grok Bot Pros: A team of bots is the easiest to understand. Free X access is amazing for research. Voice mode and the new Pages feature are great. Cons: Email feature doesn't really work. 2. Muse Pros: Free, best consumer UX, most meme-worthy avatar, and business calling is amazing. Cons: Muse Wonder is good but Opus/Astra is better. 3. Claude Duet Pros: Most proactive out of the box. Feels polished and simple to use. Arguably the best model behind it. Cons: Missing some features in research preview, like being able to drive its browser. 4. ChatGPT Dots Pros: Works inside ChatGPT, so it can drive all your cloud and local threads. Cons: Much better than at launch but still buggy. Voice mode is slow to connect. I've also tried Instinct and some of the other agents, but I don't want more than 4 at a time connected to my email. 📌 Don't miss my full Claude Duet review here for everything that it can do: https://t.co/EK28ETwWjD
Body
大家别再纠结哪个 AI 是唯一的神了， 挑 24 小时在线的个人智能体，高手的玩法从来不是四选一，而是给 4 个助理分工排班哈哈，大神@petergyang 分享的他实测的四大个人智能体最新红黑榜大家可以参考：
・Grok Bot（情报官）：吃 X 实时数据做深度研究极强，但目前弱在邮件。 ・Muse（跑腿嘴替）：给线下商家直接打电话办事一绝，但硬智力稍逊。 ・Claude Duet（高材生）：主动性与底模智商天花板，但手脚还没长齐（缺浏览器接管）。 ・ChatGPT Dots（熟练工）：无缝继承你所有历史资产，但偶发 Bug、语音偏慢。
也就是说智能体的胜负手，已经从比谁脑子聪明，变成比谁手脚勤快。
但一定要守住一条保命铁律： 绝不让超过 4 个 Agent 同时连接私人邮箱。
外行还在争天下第一， 内行已经按长板排好工位，顺手锁死了邮箱的钥匙孔。