Brockman 转引对 OpenAI 数学论文的评价
“On a technical level, the paper is unbelievable, maybe beyond what a human could have come up with but not beyond human understanding”
Greg Brockman 引用 Scott Armstrong 的推文:Armstrong 认为 OpenAI 这篇论文在技术层面令人难以置信,可能超出人类能想出的范围,但仍在人类理解之内;他还称该构造与凸积分有关,并批评那些说这一结果“毫不意外”的人在胡说。
主题
查看原帖既然我现在被 bluey 屏蔽,无法在这个帖子里回复,我就用引用推文在这里作答 OpenAI 的构造与其说与别的有关,不如说与凸积分关系更大。 在凸积分中,振荡通常是手工构造的,而迭代过程会产生狂野的弱解。Albritton–Brué–Colombo 的非唯一性构造利用了一个不稳定涡旋来把解分裂开来。Córdoba–Martínez-Zoroa 奇点则通过应变在各尺度上放大涡量。在 OpenAI 的论文中,流体不稳定性被巧妙地设计成让流动本身产生振荡:它们通过从背景剪切中汲取能量而增长。雷诺应力随后成为产生坍缩光滑涡旋的力。以这种方式利用物理不稳定性来产生应力,此前没有先例,而正是这一点产生了光滑的力,而非仅仅是粗糙的力。 其中一些想法在文献中已有(例如 Leibovich-Stewartson 1983),但它们组合起来的方式绝对是疯狂的,而且绝对在以往文献中无处可寻。 我也不知道有谁曾提出凸积分会在这种爆破解的构造中发挥作用。 从技术层面看,这篇论文令人难以置信,也许超出了人类所能想出的范围,但并未超出人类的理解范围:目前有几个不同的 PDE 专家组正在努力理解它,他们说现在或多或少已经理解了。我预计很快就会被消化吸收。 td;lr:任何说这个 OAI 结果毫不意外的人都是在胡说八道 抱歉!
查看原文
Since I'm now blocked by bluey from replying to this thread, I answer here by quote tweet the openAI construction has more to do with convex integration than anything else. In convex integration, the oscillations are typically built by hand and the iteration procedure creates wild weak solutions. The non-uniqueness construction of Albritton–Brué–Colombo used an unstable vortex to split solutions apart. The Córdoba–Martínez-Zoroa singularities amplify vorticity across scales by strain. In the openAI paper, a fluid instability is clever made so that the flow itself generates the oscillations: they grow by drawing energy from the background shear. The Reynolds stress then becomes the force that creates the collapsing smooth vortex. Using a physical instability to create the stress in this way has no precedent, and it is what produces a smooth force rather than a merely rough one. Some on these ideas are in the literature (e.g. Leibovich-Stewartson 1983) but the way they are combined is definitely insane and definitely nowhere in the literature previously. I also don't know of anyone suggesting that convex integration would play a role in the creation of a blow-up solution like this. On a technical level, the paper is unbelievable, maybe beyond what a human could have come up with but not beyond human understanding: there are several different groups of pde experts working on understanding it who say that they more or less understand now. I expect digestions soon td;lr: anyone saying that this OAI result is unsurprising is bullshitting sorry!
正文 · AI 翻译
“在技术层面上,这篇论文令人难以置信,或许超出了人类所能想出的范围,但并未超出人类的理解范围。”